Open Thread: Fire Everybody

For all the Fire Everybody-ers
Return to Homepage

Comments

Can them all!!!!

double check

Well duh.

Yes, I agree, especially McPhail and Hendry. Dusty is third on this list but yes, he should go, too. If Sandberg would come in as the interim manager, I would do it. But I doubt that Ryne is that stupid. What would be fun would be if Steve Stone got the job. It won't happen but it sure would be interesting to watch.

It won't happen but .........FIRE MCFAIL

Not me! I won't take this.

Wormer is a dead man!

Marmalard: dead!

Neidermeyer: dead!

You can't lose over the course of time the Cubs have (a century?) without doing one thing consistently, over and over again: reward incompetence.

The contract of Mr. Hendry has already been extended, so his competence/incompetence is irrelevant at this point. I don't hold him responsible for not improving the starting pitching for this year (with the September success of Williams and Rusch and the promise of least a couple of kids), but I do hold him responsible for not obtaining a quality major league back-up(s) for Lee/Ramirez, offensively and defensively, at first and third. The person he did acquire for that purpose, John Mabry, is inadequate.

I also hold him responsible for seemingly making Rich Hill an untouchable over the off season. Now I don't really think that Miguel Tejada was available at any point over the winter. But if, indeed, the Cubs could have obtained him in some package that included Hill and Cedeno (as good as Ronnie is going to be), then Hendry is a bigger idiot than I'm giving him credit for.

I also do not think it takes a good GM to just throw money (lots of it) at 30+ year old pitchers. The most promising thing about the Hendry off-season actually was Angel Pagan. I don't remember the last time the Cubs picked up someone on waivers who actually looked like he might contribute. He remains a work in progress.

As for Dusty, his lack of leadership is now breathtakingly clear and he should go. No more rewarding incompetence.

And with him should go his failure of a pitching coach, as well. It is amazing to me that Rothchild has virtually escaped blame -- not only for the injuries and lack of advancement of Cub pitchers, but also for the very consistent improvement in pitchers as soon as they leave the Cubs (Koronka being only the most recent).

This year's done. There is a nucleus for a good team in the near future. We're stuck with Hendry in the short term, so we can only hope. The Cub brass should make the other changes ASAP.

What makes everyone think Sandberg would be so terrific as a manager? What is his managerial background?

Blame the Tribune co. all you want the real reason for the cubs failures ...the fans.

If the fans would get a brain and realize nothing will change as long as they make the Cubs so profitable...they might make a dent in the trib comp bottom line and they'd be forced to sell..put out a winner or both....but the fans keep coming through the gates...buying ridiculously priced food/drink...and keep watching losers find new ways to lose.

It's you fans who support them financially during losing times at fault.

*There is a nucleus for a good team in the near future. *

Biggest lie since "There is too much talent on this team for them to be so bad."

Please.

Please, J-Damn, leave us some hope!

I place Merton, Cedeno, Ramirez, Lee, Barrett, F. Pie, Pagan, Zambrano, Marshall, Eyre and Dempster in the "nucleus" category. That's 6 out of 8 offensive starters, one bench player, two starting pitchers and two relievers -- only 14 other players to get and we're good to go!

I personally think Rothschild should be the first to be shown the door...who in this sport gets consistantly less out of more with a pitching staff then he does. I don't think there is something in the air that forces Cubs pitchers, young old, starter, relievers, to walk as many people on the other team as possible...so with that in mind, there must be something very wrong with the coaching of our pitchers.

My ranking of who should be first first down.

1st: Rotschild
2nd: Baker
3rd: Clines
4th: Hendry/McPhail

Pagan as part of your nucleus? I like him but he's strictly a complimentary player. I think Howry is more valuable.

Money, a "complimentary player" is a player who tells you you've lost some weight. A complementary player is one fills a certain niche, a role player. Maybe Pagan IS one of those, but damn, he's fast!

Yes

My Core:

D Lee
R Cedeno
M Murton
S Marshall
C Zambrano

Everyone else can be had. Prior/Wood? Who knows if they will ever be healthy? E-ramis? When is he going to get into shape to play ball? Barrett? I love the way his defense costs us big time, and few mention it.

Fire the whole coaching staff. Send up the white flag early (like today), and see what you can get for our chaff. I'd have no problem going with a young team, and one that actually looks like they want to be out in the field. I hate the way we don't hustle anymore. Even the king of hustlers JP failed to run yesterday out of the box. If a team ever needed to be dumped, this non-caring, non-hustling, non-blaming group does.

Ryno as manager? There's a guy who might give Jim Marshall a run for his money as least fierey Cub manager.

Unfortunately Jim Hendry starts out with a couple players who are "NO WAY IN HELL I WILL TRADE THEM...EVER!"

Those two players were Sammy Sosa and Kerry Wood....

The problem with this strategy is you never DO trade them...or you pay their entire salary to someone else and get nothing in return for them.

Now that list is Zambrano, Lee, Ramirez, Barrett, Dempster, Prior, Wood, and a ton of minor league players who probably never will see the light of day in the major leagues...(felix pie are you listening??).....

having a core of untradeable players is ridiculous...EVERYONE has a price....just ask George Steinbrenner....everyone can be sold, traded, bought and traded for.....you risk being a losing organization like the Cubs if you have players you will not part with.

I've been looking at every roster in the majors for a roster that we might trade all 25 players for. Probably wouldn't be any better but at least the faces would be different!

The problem is that we fans keep giving the team our money. The 'Wrigley Field Experience" has been great for all fans. I spent the better part of 15 years in the bleachers before moving to the surface of hell and truly miss it. But let's be serious the team can put any product on the field and tourist and die hards will pack the stands. Why should the trib provide a WS appearance? They get rich and we get the "experience". I hard as it is for me to say it we need to tear down Wrigley! The only way we are going to get a solid team is by having the team earn it's business. They don't have to earn anything now as we will continue to flock to this stadium.

The brainless lemmings that spend $400 at the Tibune's scalper operation for tickets, pack Wrigley and buy overpriced watered down crappy beer are definitely a big part of this. But there is more to it than that. Wrigley Field itself is the biggest impediment. The Cubs are not a baseball team, they are a circus act marched ouot to entertain the masses in Major league baseball's most reknowned tourist trap. Even if real Cubs fans finally catch on and start to stay away, their seats will be gleefully filled by tourists. Scan the crowd and see all the out of town business types and tourists with their brand new pastel colored cubs hats. Wrigley Field's so called magical atmosphere started to die out in the early 90s. I say burn down the beast! Raze it and build a new retro style park. Make this team have to earn it's following like the other teams do. In every single park in the league teams have to do that (many fail), EXCEPT THE CUBS. If that doesn't change first it doesn't matter who runs this team. Go ahead, Fire the three stooges in charge and scapegoat them. Bring in three more and let the cycle start anew. Just another sorry cycle in a sordid Cubs history.

clean house.

I'd have no problem with this, but why would the Trib ever fire McPhail? And why would McPhail fire Hendry after just extending him? This is going to be up to Hendry to make changes.

In terms of who I think should go first:

1. Clines
2. Rothschild & Baker
3. McPhail
4. Hendry

Not to say Hendry is without fault, but he has the most redeeming qualities of the guys on here, few though they may be.

Wrigley Field has become little more than a shopping mall for working professionals with deep pockets to hang out at and be seen. A minority of the people who attend games at Wrigley can be classified as "diehards" or folks who are passionate about baseball. While they all cheer for the Cubs to win, most of them don't really give a damn if the Cubs lose.

Bleacher seats go for $60 ! The secondary market for Cub tickets is a thriving business enterprise ! It doesn't matter if the Cubs win or lose on the field. Believe me, this fact is understood by the management team at Tribune Tower. Sure they'd probably like for the Cubs to win, but it isn't there biggest concern. They know they are going to make truckloads of money from the Cubs regardless whether the team is good or sucks. This equation is doubtful to change. I laugh out loud at all this boycott talk. It will never happen. If it didn't happen with the White Sox winning the World Series, it will never happen. Wrigley is just too cool of a shopping mall experience for too many.

Wrigley Field has become little more than a shopping mall for working professionals with deep pockets to hang out at and be seen. A minority of the people who attend games at Wrigley can be classified as "diehards" or folks who are passionate about baseball. While they all cheer for the Cubs to win, most of them don't really give a damn if the Cubs lose.

Bleacher seats go for $60 ! The secondary market for Cub tickets is a thriving business enterprise ! It doesn't matter if the Cubs win or lose on the field. Believe me, this fact is understood by the management team at Tribune Tower. Sure they'd probably like for the Cubs to win, but it isn't there biggest concern. They know they are going to make truckloads of money from the Cubs regardless whether the team is good or sucks. This equation is doubtful to change. I laugh out loud at all this boycott talk. It will never happen. If it didn't happen with the White Sox winning the World Series, it will never happen. Wrigley is just too cool of a shopping mall experience for too many.

"My Core:

D Lee
R Cedeno
M Murton
S Marshall
C Zambrano"

I agree but I think you have to put the back 3 of the bully (Dempster, Howry, Eyre) on that list too given that it's becoming more difficult to find decent relievers than reliable starters. Do you really want to invest $9-10 mill for a Rivera, Ryan, Wagner? There are roids rumors surrounding Gagne so that leaves Rivera, Wagner, K-rod and Nathan as the only real lockdown closers with Lidge fledling. Dempster will walk a few guys but so does Lidge and K-rod.

If Prior can return this year and put up 8-10 solid starts I definitely trade him in the off-season for another starter or a RF power hitter that isn't Abreu. If Aramis can rebound in the 2nd half I'd lose no sleep in dealing him as well.

We have to do something with the roster, the following moves should be a must to start.
1.Get rid of Neifi Perez.
2.Pick-up some righthanded hitting firstbaseman.
3.Move Todd Walker back to secondbase.
4.Or trade Todd Walker, Neifi Perez, and maybe Guzman or Hill for Alfonso Soriano at secondbase.
Notice that Todd Walker starting slumping when moved to play firstbase.
Notice that Neifi Perez is playing every game.
Imagine a lineup of when D.Lee returns.
Pierre-cf
Soriano-2b
Lee-1b
Ramirez-3b
Barrett-c
Murton-lf
Jones-rf
Cedeno-ss
We need Soriano's bat now and later. Lets get this done Jim Hendry

Don't just fire Fitzsimons, McFail, Hendry, Dusty, and the coaches. They should allow the fans to stone them all to death. The Trib could recoup most of the salary they would have to eat by selling tickets to the stoning and selling the actual stones. Then sell commemorative stones. Heck, they could engrave your personal message on the stones.
-

Make everyone on the team available but Cedeno and Murton. Not that either will be a star, but they are young players with talent and cheap salaries.

Don't you dare trade for or sign Soriano. He is a gloveless bum who swings at the first pitch and won't walk if his life depended on it. He is exactly the kind of impatient hitter the lineup is packed with now.

Hypothetically, if all of management were fired and you wanted to rebuild the team, it would take years. This team is a disaster. They also need to fire every minor league coach, farm director, and the entire scouting staff.

Whether or not one thinks either McPhail or Hendry should be fired, the question remains: why to the Cubs need both? What does McPhail do? If he's the master and Hendry is the puppet, why do they need Hendry?

There is no need to have both McPhail and Hendry.

There may also be no need to have either McPhail or Hendry, but certainly the Cubs don't need both of them

#29

Because McPhail doesn't deal with day-to-day baseball decisions. The GM does, in this scenario. He did it briefly after Lynch was canned.

Bob #30,

Then what does McPhail do? He was also the GM before he hired Lynch. I understand generally what the GM does, but see no reason for McPhail's presence.

I more-less agree that Soriano will not take pitches and the lineup is already filled with those kind of players, but what a shot in the arm offensively would he bring to the lineup. We need a star, we need a 30+ homerun/100+ RBI guy, on top of Ramirez and Lee, we just do not have enough offense as well as quality starters. I have preached this same thing all winter long, and I hate to see the Cubs play so lousey but I feel good that I was right. I blogged this way back in December, and even saved the blog. I look at it several times weekly to better understand what is happening.

McPhail is the president of the Cubs, he's been dealing more with bleacher expansion, ticket prices, rooftop owners, etc. I would venture a guess that him and Hendry are so tight that Hendry probably doesn't even have to get his approval on most personnel moves.

Fire Carrie Muskat!

#34 of 34: By Andrew (May 16, 2006 01:18 PM)
Fire Carrie Muskat!

Where then would we get our honest, unbiased, hard hitting, in depth, insider cubs news from?

#34...Comment of the Day

I think Rob nailed it on MacPhail's duties, though of course Hendry runs stuff by him...not so much for approval, just a sort of "keeping the boss in the loop" thing.

The point, Ranch, is that MacPhail doesn't make trades, doesn't make roster moves, etc. He's more corporate, I guess, at this point, than involved in nitty-gritty baseball decisions.

Thanks Bob and RobG. It seems that if McPhail was really the architect of 2 WS champs in Minnesota, that we are wasting his talents. If he wasn't really the guy who put those teams together, he's a glorified bureaucrat. Either way he doesn't carry his weight.

That said, if we put his salary towards team payroll, it probably doesn't but the Cubs very much.

Here is the problem with McFail. With the Cubs having a corporate owner, there is no ownership face to demand wins and losses. All you have is shareholders who want to see a profit.

McFail is the one person who is supposed to be making sure that the Cubs are both profitable and victorious. Unfortuantly, based on his statements that nothing is wrong with the Cubs, Hendry, or Baker even when the team is severely underperforming, its pretty clear that McFail will remain happy as long as he's got fans in seats, naming rights to sell, and new billboards to put up around the ballpark.

Andy McFail has been Team President for 12 years. Tribune management is euphoric over his performance. The primary concern is making money and adding goodwill to the corporation. The secondary concern is W's in the win column. McFail figured out that formula a long time ago, and has managed himself accordingly.

match maker com http://match-maker-com.accleaning.info/
home improvement grants for mobile homes http://homehigfmh.accufax.info/
auto transport chicago mexico http://autoatcm.abrei.info/
financing and auto loan http://financingfaal.acafamily.info/
cruises around the world http://cruisescatw.accprev.info/
pine manor apartments houston http://pinepmah.abrewebs.info/
military debt consolidation loan http://militarymdcl.absueltos.info/
individual health insurance demographics http://individualihid.accleaning.info/
fitness trainer courses http://fitness-trainer-courses.acandles.info/
toyota dealership gulf freeway http://toyotatdgf.ac-milant.info/
find a low price on toshiba notebooks http://findfalpotn.abuagabah.info/
lighting for kitchen http://lighting-for-kitchen.abuagabah.info/
natural gas fireplace valve skytech http://naturalngfvs.accufax.info/
tips for passing a drug test http://tipstfpadt.acafamily.info/
crm software australia http://crm-software-australia.acandles.info/
atlantic city new jersey poker room reviews http://atlanticacnjprr.topweb.ltd.pl/
hotels with wedding chapel in reno nv http://hotelshwwcirn.abunti.info/
wholesale oakley sunglasses http://wholesale-oakley-sunglasses.ac-milant....
siemens phone system http://siemens-phone-system.acdcrules.info/
buy tapeworm diet pills http://buybtdp.mlinks.kom.pl/
national dental plans inc http://nationalndpi.ac-milant.info/
exotic car rentals memphis2c tn http://exoticecrmt.abunti.info/
casino chips fort worth http://casinoccfw.mlinks.ltd.pl/
schools in feng shui interior design http://schoolssifsid.acdcrules.info/
tailors hall hotel in edinburgh http://tailorsthhie.abso-bvos.info/

term life vs whole life insurance http://termtlvwli.abrei.info/
1999 chevrolet suburban repair http://19991csr.abunti.info/
cheap honeymoon vacation http://cheap-honeymoon-vacation.abuagabah.info/
zocor genieric http://zocor-genieric.abstemios.info/
fax thru email http://fax-thru-email.abunti.info/
international toll free access calling cards http://internationalitfacc.abstemios.info/
phone fax message server email http://phonepfmse.abunti.info/
safety ear plugs http://safety-ear-plugs.acandles.info/
airline tickets 2f cheap 2f lowest fares http://airlineat2c2lf.abso-bvos.info/
palm data acquisition system http://palmpdas.abso-bvos.info/
debt settlement offersa0 http://debt-settlement-offersa0.abstemios.info/
internet casino gambling online http://interneticgo.abunti.info/
the breakers palm beach florida moon http://thetbpbfm.abstemios.info/
martha stewart patio umbrella parts http://marthamspup.abunti.info/
do fat loss creams really work http://dodflcrw.acalawns.info/
chevrolet suburban wheel center caps http://chevroletcswcc.abunti.info/
timberland shoes in massachusetts http://timberlandtsim.armcogolfclub.info/
pet assure insurance http://pet-assure-insurance.accomic.info/
round umbrella patio planters http://roundrupp.abunti.info/
cars bmw cooper http://cars-bmw-cooper.accprev.info/
beau geste pheromone http://beau-geste-pheromone.abso-bvos.info/
kimberley hotel hong kong http://kimberleykhhk.abstemios.info/
how long does lortab stay in your system http://howhldlsiys.armeniansgroup.info/
direct line motor insurance uk http://directdlmiu.abreulog.info/
caribbean islands travel ideas and sights http://caribbeancitias.abreulog.info/

X
  • Sign in with Twitter