Game 161 Thread / Cubs @ Reds (2 of 3)

Game Chat Rich Hill vs. Aaron Harang Lineups: Who Cares?


"Lineups: Who Cares?"

thread of the year.

What do you think the playoff roster is going to b Phil? I see Blanco, Monroe, Trax and maybe Eyre left off.

my name's not phil, but im a loudmouth, so whatever...

monroe's probably got a 'bye' into the postseason cuz he's a righty who can cover all 3 OF slots. JJ cant be risked to cover CF by himself and pie's barely worked recently (and is a lefty).

monroe could/probably make it based solely on his given tools, independent of his batting performance so far.

I still think the lineup sucks.

Great photo, btw, Brick. Thanks.

God, I'm an idiot. Or I'm still drunk. Either way, I forgot that THAT'S how you put a big photo into Word Press. Thanks, Rob!

or you could resize the photo so it doesn't take an hour to download :)

Mets up 5-0 in the 2nd....

so how bad would it be for the Phils to go up a game and then blow it?

and Eyre will make the roster, he's been pretty lights out since the ASB (0.84 ERA)

I do wonder how short the leash will be on Dumpster?

Thanks, Brick.

It looks great on my desktop!

mets got angry today, 7-0 in the 3rd



Go Brewers!

rob g.

that was good....


get all the cubs music at

go cubs go ! ! !


Brick's photo is awesome.

Now 8-0 Mets...someone put something in the pregame spread, I think.

BP Odds Report on Playoff Opponents:

The way things shook out last night, it really looks like we will face the Diamondbacks, an 82.5% chance. There is an outside 12.5% shot of facing the Padres, a 3.5% chance of meeting the Phillies, and 1.5% chance of meeting the Mets.

The odds of a Wild Card tie decreased significantly yesterday with the Rockies and Mets losing and the Diamondbacks and Padres winning.

I like our chances against the Diamondbacks, in part because Phoenix is a familiar environment for the team. Essentially the entire major and minor league coaching and training staff will be available to them. I don't want to come within 100 miles of the Phillies this October.

so if eyre and monroe are in, whos out? ohman and pie?

An angry Mets team is no fun either. Man, it is NOT going to be easy.

OK, I'll bite. Here's my 25-man roster for the first round:






I'm assuming that Uncle Lou will want 11 pitchers, and he'll be able to get by with four starters. I can't Monroe making it, he's just not done well enough, and Blanco has barely played at all in the last month.Ohman makes the team as a LOOGY. We don't have a long man, but hopefully we won't need one - I can't recall a game this year where a long man was brought in to pitch the bulk of a game when the starter faltered. Marshall and Trachsel are ready reserves, in case someone gets hurt.

Just my $0.02 worth.

Umm, does anyone actually know the lineup? It interests me.

thanks Brick, your photo looks fantastic as a desktop for my 20" apple monitor!

Lineup - um, someone in another thread and chat mentioned Dave Veres picking up a few innings today.

What I heard anyway.

just speculation now, hendry has a few days to submit the playoff roster.

veres, hahah:)

no marshall urbs?

Yeah, I send Marshall in a millisecond over Ohman.

On, it shows Gallagher getting the spot start over Rich Hill...

i hate u fox.

evidently the mets are in a fighting move...and i can't see it.

its being described as "classic" amongst other things.

fighting mood...

lots of punches, multiple bench clearings...


theriot, fontenot, murton, Soto, Pie, Cedeno (3B), Blanco (1B), Fuld (RF), Hill


Hopper, Keppinger, Votto, Phillips, Encarnacion, Cantu, Ross, Ellison

I expect some of the regulars to get a couple of Ab's tomorrow.

Maine's throwing a no-no as well into the 7th

Interesting... Theriot is the one guy whom I thought would sit for sure because of his back. But it makes sense to get Cedeno some defensive reps at 3B in case he's needed there during the playoffs.

I turn to fox to see if they cut to the Mets game and lo and behold, it's the Cubs v. Reds!!!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!

I love this line-up!

This lineup su.... er, it's fine with me!

Theroit could have used an offday. I probably would have called up Fox put him at 1b and put Blanco at 3rd. Though I guess if he sits tomrrow that is still 3 days off before Game 1.

I'd like Brick's photograph in high resolution, please. Care to post it?

They're not showing the Cubs game on Fox in Chicago? Seriously? Somebody explain this.

Nevermind, it's on WGN. Still, I don't understand.

Too funny. I predicted this exact line-up last night with the exception of Cedeno at 3B instead of Theriot.

Hopefully, a sign of good things to come from Murton and Cedeno.

Ladies and Gentlemen, please welcome your 2006-2007 Iowa Cubs to Great American Ballpark!

too bad they are going to pull hill, he's allowed no baserunners

so... anyone else be tempted to start Cedeno over Theriot in the playoffs?

Jacque Jones with bunny ears on Sweet Lou during Fox's in-game commentary. Love it.

Well, the Chicago Cubs can't beat Harang, but the Iowa Cubs don't have much problem doing it.

Combined 1-hit shutout? Wow....

Didn't anybody tell the pitchers that this game was meaningless?

Hey Rich Hill and bullpen


"Yeah, I send Marshall in a millisecond over Ohman."

I'm thinking that Ohman has experience as a LOOGY, while Marshall would need time to warm up. But today's performance was pretty impressive - granted, against an utterly demoralized Reds team. No doubt Uncle Lou and Jim will confound all our predictions.

Marshall looked pretty healthy to me.........looked like he was throwing free and easy.

AP - "Piniella wasn't aware that several Marlins suggested the Cubs were panicking while they got swept in Florida on Thursday. ``You know, they've got a lot of talent over there to lose 90 games,'' Piniella said, pointedly. ``Outside of that, I don't have much to say about the situation.''

I love it! Go Lou!!

F*** the fish!

Haven't caught any of the brawl story today but seems like the fish were letting the 'spoiler' role go to their heads.

yeah, evidently marshall's pretty good at pitching on 2 weeks rest.

a lot better than pitching on 8 days rest, anyway.

good to see him out there today...was worried about his state of health seeing so little of him.

there's a "cubs special" hour-long running on WGN right now.

And most people were worried about the Reds series because there was NO way we could beat both Arroyo and Harang....the B team had no problem with Harang.

Great song-

I'm watching it too, crunch.

Another great song-

And also my game entrance song from the bullpen if I were a closer.

They just showed the rookies walking out of the clubhouse in the costumes.


Ah, schucks. I missed the first 20 mins of the Cubs special. Have to watch for when it airs again.

URBS: "I’m thinking that Ohman has experience as a LOOGY..."


No Fucking WAY! ANYONE ELSE. He is not a LOOGY. Not a ROOGY!

Leave this crap-ass pitcher with Trachsel OFF the Roster. PLEASE, LOU!

My gift to you-


Ohman IS a LOOGY. That doesn't mean we need one, but he is good in that role. I personally want Marshall on the roster though. Good the entire season except for one month. Maybe he just got tired, because he looked every bit as dominating as he did the first three months.

Please let him pitch over Marquis (I know, ain't happening, but I can hope.)

"The Cubs are the first team in the NL Central to go from last to first in consecutive seasons. The last NL team to pull off the feat was Arizona in 1999",

As per my request to CHAD, Cubs are in elite company as he did some research on this previously and found that only five teams have done this during the last 30 years.

We're in elite company.


You may now change your moniker back to CWTP!


They’re not showing the Cubs game on Fox in Chicago? Seriously? Somebody explain this.

I mentioned it a couple days ago, Fox is only allowed to carry one team up to 9 times. Today was the 10th game for the Cubs, so it was blacked out in Chicago. I'm still not sure how WGN then gets the rights to a Saturday afternoon, when that's supposed to be Fox's exclusive time...

BTW, Thanks Brick. Your photo is now my desktop wallpaper.

Hill's 4 K's gave him 183 on the year which will likely give him the team lead unless Lilly can strike out 10 in his 2-3 innings of work tomorrow.

He also lowered his ERA under the 4 mark to 3.92 which will likely be 2nd on the team behind Lilly unless he gets rocked tomorrow.

Marshall also lowered his ERA to 3.92 with his 2 innings.

All 5 Cubs starters (I'm using Marshall) with ERA+ over 100.


What a terrific shot!

Many, many thanks!

Jacos - That is hysterical!! =D

a blast from the past...

for those of us that have only heard the Lee Elia tirade with is the real deal, 4-29-83:

Brick, thanks for the picture!

Jacos, thanks for the video!

This is too much fun.

You know, they’ve got a lot of talent over there to lose 90 games


VA Phil - Lou is making fun of your Marlins!

I think the choice for the 11th pitcher will come down to Kevin Hart or Marshall. Based on experience, he would be a second lefty out of the pen, and how he looked today, you would think Marshall will get the nod. Hart has looked very good this month, though.

Well Elias was half right about the '83 Cubs, they would hit. More than could be said for the 2006 version.


What do you think about this? When it happens?

Recent comments

Subscribe to Recent comments
The first 600 characters of the last 16 comments, click "View" to see rest of comment.
  • Jake Arrieta gives up first inning run

    For the first time in a year, 33 starts.

    //not really

    jacos 32 min 19 sec ago view
  • Old news, sorry if it's 3/44-

    J-Hey being classy by repaying an old teammate:

    Ryno 1 hour 10 min ago view
  • Sigh.

    Ok... maybe.

    Ryno 1 hour 36 min ago view
  • With Paredes moving to 3B, how do you see playing time shaking out between him and Galindo? Do you think Galindo gets starts at 1B? Galindo is more of a prospect than Paniagua, right?

    bradsbeard 1 hour 38 min ago view
  • Phil, your knowledge of the Cubs Minor League system is unbelievable.

    Hagsag 1 hour 41 min ago view
  • This kid would be a key piece in a trade for a pitcher, imo.

    The E-Man 1 hour 44 min ago view
  • This might be old news but Hammel was on ESPN 1000 and said that he changed his diet and workout routine over the off season and tweaked his delivery so it'd be more repeatable so he'd have a better second half. So...some cause for optimism anyway.

    johann 3 hours 5 min ago view
  • CHILDERS: RHSP Dylan Cease and LHSP Bryan Hudson are probably the top two SP prospects in the organization right now. 

    LHSP Jose Paulino has electric stuff (91-94 MPH fastball with sinking action and a mid-80's slider), but he also has trouble commanding it.  

    RHP Jose Albertos (2015 IFA - Mexico - $1.5M bonus) just turned 17 in November, and his fastball already sits at 95-96. He also throws a curve and a change-up, and is fairly advanced for a kid his age.   

    Arizona Phil 3 hours 13 min ago view
  • AZBOBBOP: Most of 2016 draft picks will get assigned to either Eugene or AZL Cubs, but the Opening Day Eugune roster will probably be almost 100% from the Extended Spring Training squad roster (pending the arrival of draft picks).

    I think I can probably tell you which pitchers and players at EXST are in contention for roster slots at Eugene and which are in contention for slots with the AZL Cubs - AS THINGS STAND RIGHT NOW - (listed alphabetically):  

    * bats or throws left 
    # bats both

    Arizona Phil 3 hours 41 min ago view
  • Eloy Jimenez atop the leader board for minor-league home runs in the Cub system, with seven. Tied with Balaguert and Vogelbach, two 24-year-olds. Jimenez won't be 20 until late November. Leads the Midwest League in SLG and OPS. Maybe he'll get promoted to the Myrtle Beach squad that visits Woodbridge, VA, in June or Frederick, MD, in August.

    Watched two Pelican games at Frederick the other week. Was most impressed by Stinnett and Happ. Happ may swing harder than Javier Baez, though more compactly. (Also got to see Brockmeyer hit a bomb.)

    VirginiaPhil 4 hours 3 min ago view
  • E-MAN: Jose Paniagua isn't a string-bean, but I wouldn't say he necessarily bulked-up during the 2015-16 off-season  either, He led the DSL Cubs in HR and doubles in 2014, and he showed XBH power when he arrived in Mesa last year, leading the AZL Cubs in HR, doubles, and RBI in 2015. It's just that he has taken his HR power to a new level this year.

    Paniagua displayed plus-HR power in Cactus League Minor League Spring Training games in March, and that got him a slot on the South Bend Opening Day roster. But he was sent to EXST after only six MWL games.  

    Arizona Phil 4 hours 9 min ago view
  • Rob Richardson 4 hours 39 min ago view
  • Martinez is one of my least favorite pitchers in baseball. I'd love to see a game like yesterday's against him.

    Send Soler down!

    Old and Blue 5 hours 32 min ago view
  • Awesome thanks AZ

    Old and Blue 5 hours 35 min ago view
  • Great report, Phil! This organization has so many hitters to be excited about.

    John Beasley 6 hours 24 min ago view
  • Ben Zobrist is very enjoyable to watch!!!!!!

    Hagsag 9 hours 12 min ago view