The Ides of April
Déjà Vu all over again, Alfonso? For the second time in two years during mid April, Cubs star left fielder Alsonso Soriano injured a leg.
Last year he missed just a week from a mild left hamstring strain on April 16th. He returned to the lineup by April 22nd but was limited in his running as well as his outfield play for a few weeks after that injury.
Here was the immediate reaction to last April's injury on cubs.com:
...his status is day-to-day. The center fielder was injured when he dove trying to catch Clay Hensley's single with one out and a runner at second in the fifth. "I don't like to be hurt," Soriano said. "I like to play every day. We'll see how I feel tomorrow."
This isn't to be confused with his more significant right quadriceps strain last August 6th. I vividly remember seeing Soriano pull up lame after rounding 2nd base against the Mets in the game Tom Glavine got his 300th win. Third base coach Mike Quade helped Alfonso off the field that evening. Soriano returned to action by August 28th.
In last night's game vs the Reds, while making the third out in the top of the 1st inning by catching a flyball from Ken Griffey Jr. and doing his signature hop to make the catch, Soriano once again came up lame. He needed to use CF Felix Pie to limp off the field. In the bottom of the inning he was replaced by Mike Fontenot with Mark DeRosa taking his spot in LF.
Again cubs.com says (Carrie Muskat must have a macro key for her Word application regarding this stuff. Ironically, when she hits the F7 key, the macro spits out something about being day-to-day):
Cubs outfielder Alfonso Soriano had to leave Tuesday's game after the top of the first inning with a strained right calf. His status was day-to-day.
This time the preliminary diagnosis is a strained right calf. To recap the anatomy, the quadriceps is the major muscle in the front of the thigh. The hamstrings are the muscles behind the thigh. The larger muscles that make up
the calf are the gastrocnemius which
is more superficial and the deeper soleus which blend together as they go toward
the lower portion of the leg until they connect with the achilles
tendon. They are responsible for pushoff in running activity. Just like
any other muscle injury they are graded by extent of injury, rarely
need surgery and usually take from 2-6 weeks to heal.They shipped Soriano off for an MRI Tuesday night so the results will be available in the morning. Hearing Lou Piniella on the postgame interview, he didn't sound optimistic with the most recent comp injury being Phillie OF Shane Victorino who was put on the 15 day DL the day after his calf strain on Saturday. Matt Murton, Jake Fox or Eric Patterson...please check your answering machines.
It could be worse. The Ides of April ruined the 2006 Season on April 19th when Scott Eyre fielded a Raphael Furcal bunt. The sooner they get this month over with the safer I will feel.
UPDATE: It's official. Eric Patterson gets the call-up as Fonzie goes on the 15 day DL. Stay tuned for the Patterson brothers reunion deathmatch tonight.









Twitter RSS for TCR
#1 Re: The Ides of April
I'll just say it:
If Soriano is going to the DL...
Barry Lamar Bonds
Sammy Peralta Sosa
Discuss
#3 Re: The Ides of April
We couldn't do Bonds because Carrie Muskat doesn't have an MS Word macro tied to "will miss several games owing to obligations in federal court."
Great write-up, Doc.
I'm glad we still have Murton and I hope he's the guy who gets the call. DeRosa cannot and should not be in the outfield.
#5 Re: The Ides of April
We'll know if Barry is on his way to the Cub's if we see these things getting installed around the clubhouse:
http://www.gokulamhealthcare.com/images/products/N...
#2 Re: The Ides of April
Discuss
Nope.
#4 Re: The Ides of April
Pretty sure we caught "gastrocnemius" in Vegas last year... little penicillin clears that right up.
#12 Re: The Ides of April
TLFC,
Can Ted play left? He sure as hell can't pitch but maybe we can get something out of that big contract.
#6 Re: The Ides of April
Bonds-no
Sammy-no
April 2005-Nomar goes down
April 2006-Dlee goes down
April 2007- Prior is shut down
#7 Re: The Ides of April
Any idea how long it will be before the results of the MRI are known?
#8 Re: The Ides of April
Pinella is already saying Soriano could be "out a while"
Good thing we kept Murton.
#9 Re: The Ides of April
Maybe it's just me, but it always seems like this type of injury could only happen to the Cubs. Could another option for Lou be to play Pie in CF and move Reed over to LF?
#10 Re: The Ides of April
It's just you. This type of injury happens to every team in the league.
#24 Re: The Ides of April
No this injury does happen when running out ground outs, stretching extra base hits, or chasing fly balls into gaps.
Hopping like a retarted rabbit for a routine fly ball and getting injured is a new one.
#11 Re: The Ides of April
RE: Discuss
I'd rather have Murton than either one of the them. I'm actually kind of happy for the big friendly red-head. Go get em Orange Guy.
#21 Re: The Ides of April
I really hope Murt gets the call. Soriano's contract is already an albatross and we have 7 more years of the guy. Not only will he likely never again get close to 46 HRs, but we'll be lucky to get 15 SBs out of him. Along with his requisite 150+ ugly Ks we've got ourselves Sammy Sosa circa 2004-05, without the bad attitude but with an untradeable contract.
We know Murt can hit ML pitching. He might never develop huge power, and he doesn't have blazing speed, but we need to keep him since "Glass Leg" Soriano can't stay healthy.
#39 Re: The Ides of April
I like Murt alot, but lets get a little grip on reality here.
Soriano who "can't stay healthy" played in 135 games last year, and that was the fewest games he'd played basically his entire major league career. Now he might be out for a couple weeks -not a couple of months- maybe a couple of weeks. If he's made of glass, then you can certainly say the same thing about ARam, and about 50% of the league.
And Soriano's contract is hardly an albatross at this point. When Torii Hunter and Andrew Jones are making $18 million a year as Free Agents, Soriano's contract starts to look very affordable.
#49 Re: The Ides of April
You're right. I definitely overreacted a bit, and obviously Soriano is a better player than Murton. I think the frustration over all these leg injuries and the poor start is catching up to me.
I really dont want this happen, but Soriano is turning into one of those players that I hate to watch. A) He doesn't belong at leadoff but somehow he's convinced that's the only spot in the lineup he can produce at, B) He can't steal bases anymore, which was a huge reason why he got the big contract (Power + Speed = Big Contract), C) He swings at TERRIBLE pitches and strikes out constantly, D) He gets injured doing idiotic things like hopping unnecessarily for fly balls.
He seems like a generally good guy, and I'm sure a hot week or two will cure me temporarily of my disdain for him, but I just can't see how this will look like a good signing in years 5-8 (and I hope it doesn't turn horrible even sooner than that).
To summarize my thoughts:
Soriano > Murton
Murton > Most LF bench options
It's damn good we didn't trade Murton, because who knows how many more leg injuries Soriano's got in store for us.
#23 Re: The Ides of April
lol @ TCR and it's man-crush on a mediocre AAAA player.
#13 Re: The Ides of April
Wait someone wants to play Felix "Oh shit its another curve" Pie AND put Reed Johnson in LF? Wow just wow.
#16 Re: The Ides of April
wait, someone thinks Reed Johnson is going to keep hitting .300 if he has to start facing righties consistently?
#14 Re: The Ides of April
top IOwa Cubs hitters right now...
Bobby Scales: 304/360/652
Murton 294/442/294
Andre Torres 292/393/542
Jake Fox 261/261/565
...
...
...
Epat 222/282/444
#15 Re: The Ides of April
Based on Lou's comments at the end of ST, I think it's quite obvious Murton gets called up to replace Sori.
#17 Re: The Ides of April
Ohh and Rich Hill's next start will not be pushed back now. Which means Hill's starts wont be skipped if he was the #5 guy.
See, nothing more than Lou doing his version of motivation.
#18 Re: The Ides of April
Lou is a motivational juggler in this circus of a team.
#19 Re: The Ides of April
if it is not matt
murton now it will
never be matt murton
#20 Re: The Ides of April
"Wait someone wants to play Felix "Oh shit its another curve" Pie AND put Reed Johnson in LF? Wow just wow."
I wasn't suggesting that should be what the club should do here, but was it a viable option. And what if the club had succeeded in finding Murton a new home before the end of ST? You don't think they had considered what their options would be in that case if Soriano had gone down with another injury?
#22 Re: The Ides of April
"Soriano's contract is already an albatross"
Climb back off the ledge Doug.
#52 Re: The Ides of April
Duly noted, and see my response above to Bleeding Blue.
#25 Re: The Ides of April
I wonder if the Cub's could make an offer good enough to net David DeJesus from KC.
Pie, Murt, and Hart for DD? Fuck yea, I'd do it.
#26 Re: The Ides of April
"we've got ourselves Sammy Sosa circa 2004-05, without the bad attitude but with an untradeable contract."
The biggest Myth Cubs fans readily believe. Based on nothing more than Sosa is an Ass-Hole because he couldnt keep hitting 60 HR's a year.
Sosa is just as nice and fun loving as Soriano. Soriano will likely end up with the label of a "bad apple" by time he leaves Chicago as well.
2002, 2003 people were calling Sosa a bum because he hit a shitty 49 and 40 HR's. I never saw a player take so much crap from a fan base for doing nothing more than being human.
Ohh but it was because he sucked with RISP those years. Yeah i guess a 1.000 OPS sucks.
#54 Re: The Ides of April
You can get away with a lot when you're hitting 60+ HRs a year. I don't know Sosa personally, and I expect neither do you, but it seems that anecdotally most of his teammates thought he was a prick.
Return to Homepage