2008 Rule 4 Draft

Quick Update(Rob G.): Scout.com has a live blog going for the draft and they'll be answering user questions. The writer running it is hearing that the Cubs will not pass on Casey Kelly if he's available. Also, Parachat is (always) open if you want to chat amongst yourselves.


The MLB Rule 4 Draft (AKA “First-Year Player Draft”) starts at 2 PM ET today, with the 1st round and Supplemental 1st round to be televised "live" on ESPN2. The draft will continue tomorrow (Friday). Last year, the first five rounds of the draft were completed by the end of the first day, and the remaining 45 rounds were completed by the end of the second day.

With the selections to be made by Scouting Director Tim Wilken, the Cubs will have the 19th pick in the first round, one selection in the Supplemental 1st Round (the 41st pick overall, compensation for losing FA catcher Jason Kendall to MIL), one selection in the 2nd round (65th overall), one selection in the 3rd round (97th overall), one selection in the 4th round (131st overall), and then every 30 picks (#161, #191, #221, #251, etc) after that until the 50 rounds (maximum) are completed. Clubs have until August 15th to sign their draft picks. Players who are not selected in the draft can sign with any club as a Non-Drafted Free-Agent (NDFA).

The name most-often mentioned as the Cubs 1st round target is RHP-SS Casey Kelly (Sarasota HS - Sarasota , FL), the son of one-time Yankees 2B Pat Kelly.

The younger Kelly has signed an NLI to play quarterback at the University of Tennessee, so signing him could be a problem. However, if a team fails to sign a 1st (or 2nd) round pick in a given year, it gets a replacement pick one slot lower in the 1st round (or 2nd) round of the following year's draft, so all would not be lost if (for example) Kelly is selected but does not sign. (Not signing a 3rd round pick nets a club a compensation pick between the 3rd and 4th rounds in the following year's draft).

Also, Canadian Junior National Team slugging 3B Brett Lawrie and Las Vegas Durango HS SS Niko Vasquez worked-out at Fitch Park in Mesa last weekend (Vasquez even played in Saturday's EXST game, and he hit a HR!), so don't be surprised if the Cubs select Lawrie in the 1st round (if available) and Vasquez (if available) either with their Supplemental 1st round selection, or in the 2nd round.

In addition, TCU RHP Andrew Cashner (a college closer with an upper 90's fastball) is rated a potential 1st round pick, and he has a Cubs connection, too. Cashner was selected by the Cubs in the 29th round of last year's draft out of Angelina JC, but he didn't get the money he wanted, so he transferred to TCU for his junior year and proceeded to light it up.

The Cubs do have a history of drafting players they like two years in a row, most-recently Stanford OF Sam Fuld (24th round in 2003 and 10th round in 2004) and Clemson 3B Marquez Smith (35th round in 2006 and 8th round in 2007).

Last year, the Cubs signed 33 of their 50 Rule 4 selections, including their first 18 picks, 23 of their first 24, and 28 of their first 32. Of the 33 who signed, six have subsequently been released, and one retired. .

Only eight of the Cubs 2007 Rule 4 Draft selections were high school players, and the Cubs signed only two of the eight (3B Josh Vitters and RHP Ryan Acosta).

Here are last year's Cubs Rule 4 selections, and where they are now:

NOTE: Players who signed with Cubs in bold

* bats or throws left
# bats both

2007 RULE 4 DRAFT
1. Josh Vitters, 3B (Cypress HS – Cypress, CA) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
2. Josh Donaldson, C (Auburn) - at Peoria
3. Tony Thomas, 2B (Florida State) - at Daytona
4. Darwin Barney, SS (Oregon State) - at Daytona
5. Brandon Guyer, OF (Virginia) - at Peoria
6. * Casey Lambert, P (Virginia) - at Daytona
7. Ty Wright, OF (Oklahoma State) - at Daytona
8. Marquez Smith, 3B (Clemson) - at Peoria
9. * Clark Hardman, OF (Cal State- Fullerton) - at Fitch Park (DL)
10. * Leon Johnson, OF (BYU) - at Peoria
11. * Chris Siegfried, P (U. of Portland) - at Peoria
12. Ryan Acosta, P (Clearwater Central Catholic HS - Clearwater, FL) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
13. * Jonathan Wyatt, OF (Georgia) - at Daytona
14. * James Russell, P (Texas) - at Tennessee
15. * Marc Sawyer, 1B (Yale) - RETIRED
16. * Zach Ashwood, P (Kansas) - at Peoria
17. * Arik Hempy, P (South Carolina) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
18. * Jeffrey Rea, 2B (Mississippi State) - at Fitch Park (DL)
19. * Kyle Day, C (Michigan State) - DID NOT SIGN
20. Jose Made, SS (Dominican College) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
21. * Dustin Sasser, P (East Carolina) - at Peoria
22. Craig Muschko, P (LaSalle) - at Peoria
23. Stephen Vento, P (Palm Beach CC) - at Peoria
24. Scott Meyer, P (Lamar) - RELEASED
25. Victor Sanchez, 3B (Gahr HS – Norwalk, CA) - DID NOT SIGN (enrolled at University of San Diego)
26. * Michael Bunton, P (College of Charleston) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
27. Clayton Suss, P (Cooper City HS - Cooper City, FL) - DID NOT SIGN (enrolled at Miami-Dade CC)
28. Bill Moss, 2B (U. of Memphis) - RELEASED
29. Andrew Cashner, P (Angelina JC) - DID NOT SIGN (transferred to TCU)
30. * Luke Sommer, OF (U. of San Francisco) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
31. * Brian Leclerc, OF (Florida) - RELEASED
32. Luis Bautista, C (Florida International) - at PEORIA
33. Preston Clark, C (Texas) - DID NOT SIGN
34. Enrique Garcia, P (U. of Miami) - DID NOT SIGN
35. J. C. Casey, P (Kickapoo HS – Kickapoo, MO) - DID NOT SIGN (enrolled at Missouri State)
36. * Billy Mottram, 3B (Dowling College) - RELEASED
37. Mike McGee, 3B/P (Port St. Lucie HS – Port St. Lucie, FL) - DID NOT SIGN (enrolled at Florida State)
38. Yuri Higgins, P (South Florida) - RELEASED
39. Roberto Sabates, C (CUBAN DEFECTOR - Miami, FL) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
40. Corey Bachman, P (VMI) - RELEASED
41. Jordan Herr, OF (Pitt) - DID NOT SIGN
42. Colt Sedbrook, 2B (Arizona) - DID NOT SIGN
43. Garrett Clyde, P (San Jacinto JC – North) - DID NOT SIGN (transferred to U. of Texas)
44. * Bryan Jost, 1B (Minnesota) - at Fitch Park (EXST)
45. Ryan Lewis, OF (Yakima Valley CC) - DID NOT SIGN (transferred to Westen Oregon)
46. Tyler Clark, P (Springfield Catholic HS – Springfield, MO) - DID NOT SIGN (enrolled at U. of Missouri)
47. Josh Walter, P (Texas State) - DID NOT SIGN
48. Carlos Rivera, OF (East Aurora HS - East Aurora, IL) - DID NOT SIGN (enrolled at Waubonsee CC)
49. Jordan Rogers, P (San Jacinto JC - North) - DID NOT SIGN (transferred to Rice)
50. Blake Murphy, C (Western Carolina) - DID NOT SIGN

NDFA:
Patrick Brooks, INF (UT - Pan American) - RELEASED
Michael Christl, P (Bradley) - RELEASED
* Matt Hudgins, C (Virginia Wesleyan) - RELEASED
Chris Rivera, P (Virginia Wesleyan) - RELEASED
Derek Schermerhorn, 1B (Wichita State) - RELEASED

Comments

BTW, for thos interested, Kyle Day, the unsigned 19th pick remained at Michigan State where he just completed his junior season. He had another good season at the plate, hitting .320, .448, .543. In 175 at-bats he led the team in runs (41), RBI (48), total bases (95), homeruns (9), walks (39), as well as slugging and on base percentage. He was 6-8 in steals to boot. We will probably see him taken higher this year by someone.

AZ Phil,

Who did the Cubs "lose" that got them a supplemental sandwich pick? I can not remember any of our free agents last year being a Type B free agent.

Submitted by Chifan on Thu, 06/05/2008 - 8:58am.

AZ Phil,

Who did the Cubs "lose" that got them a supplemental sandwich pick? I can not remember any of our free agents last year being a Type B free agent.

============================

CHIFAN: Jason Kendall

Thanks for the info. It takes a little of the sting away from losing Jerry Blevans.

Great write up Dr. Phil. In your opinion of the guys drafted and not signed last year. Who helped themselves by not signing? Who wishes they had a mulligan? I'll hang up and listen.

After watching the Padres series I am thankful the human garbage that is Barret is gone. It was like Lou Pinella was saying "That, that was our catcher? Watch as I run my players at will against him." That's what it was like being a Cubs fan watching him catch games as other teams ran on us for years.

In last nights game Len saild only two NL starting catchers did not have homeruns-

Barrett
Kendall

Thank you, Jebus for Soto.

Is that a mix of Jobu and Jesus? And did we have to sacrafice a live chicken to get Soto?

Come on - at least be honest.

Barrett only has 11 games and 40 at-bats this year, as he was hurt.

True, but he also hasn't homered since the trade - which is over 170 AB's.

Sure... but that is a different conversation.

To imply that someone it is meaningful that Barrett has not homered this year is just silly.

And FWIW... the announcers didn't talk about starting catchers not homering. They talked about the teams' catchers not homering. Neither Milwaukee or San Diego have ANY home runs from ANY of their catchers.

Submitted by Dr. aaron b on Thu, 06/05/2008 - 9:16am.

Great write up Dr. Phil.

In your opinion of the guys drafted and not signed last year. Who helped themselves by not signing? Who wishes they had a mulligan? I'll hang up and listen.

============================

DR AARON B: The only two 2007 Cubs draft picks who really "got away" were Angelina JC RHP Andrew Cashner (who transferred to TCU) and Norwalk, CA (Gahr HS) and Team USA Junior National Team 3B Victor Sanchez (who enrolled at the U. of San Diego).

The 6'6 Cashner wanted "1st round money" to sign last year (which is why he fell to the 29th round) and he did (in fact) turn out to be probably the #1 closer prospect in the 2008 draft (96-98 MPH fastball and 84-85 MPH slider), and Sanchez fell to the 25th round because he also wanted "1st round money" (he was rated maybe a 3rd-4th round "talent" coming out of HS), and now he is a likely Freshman All-American at USD and is everything the Cubs hoped Josh Vitters would be, except Sanchez can actually play 3B.

Unfortunately for the Cubs, the Draft & Follow (DNF) rule was eliminated beginning with this year's draft, meaning the Cubs did not retain the rights to Cashner up to one week before the 2008 draft as they would have in years past. In any other year previous, they could have given Cashner 1st round money as a DNF (like the Diamondbacks did with Max Scherzer a year ago) and still retained their #1 pick. 

The Cubs should have given Sanchez the 1st round money they gave to Vitters, let Vitters go to Arizona State, and then the Cubs would have ended up with Sanchez AND they would have picked up the #5 overall pick in this year's draft as compensation for not signing Vitters. (BTW, because he enrolled in a four-year college, Sanchez will not be eligible for the Rule 4 Draft again until June 2010).

As for who should have signed when they had the chance, I would say University of Texas (and Team USA) catcher Preston Clark, who fell into the 30's for "signability" reasons a year ago and now has less value than ever (he should have followed the lead of buddy James Russell and signed with the Cubs when he had the chance), San Jacinto JC RHP Jordan Rogers (now at Rice), Kickapoo HS RHP J. C. Casey (who struggled at Missouri State), OF Jordan Herr (Pitt), and 2B Colt Sedbrook (Arizona).

AZ Phil,

Last year at this time the debate here was should they have drafted Jarrod Parker over Vitters. Given the added benefit of what they have done as pros so far do you think Hendry made a mistake? Parker in 39.2 IP in Low-A South Bend has 34/10 K/BB ratio with 39 hits and 2 HR with a 2.73 ERA. Or was the right move not signing anyone with the 4th pick and taking the 5th pick this year and signing a guy like Cashner or Sanchez?

I think the debate was Wieter vs Vitters...Parker was a longshot at the #3 spot, although the Cubs did have interest.

Submitted by Chifan on Thu, 06/05/2008 - 10:42am.

AZ Phil,

Last year at this time the debate here was should they have drafted Jarrod Parker over Vitters. Given the added benefit of what they have done as pros so far do you think Hendry made a mistake?

Parker in 39.2 IP in Low-A South Bend has 34/10 K/BB ratio with 39 hits and 2 HR with a 2.73 ERA.

Or was the right move not signing anyone with the 4th pick and taking the 5th pick this year and signing a guy like Cashner or Sanchez?

=============================

CHIFAN: I thought at the time that the Cubs should have let Vitters "slip away" (remember, he didn't sign until the very last minute) and instead give the money to Sanchez, and then take the #5 overall pick in the 2008 draft as compensation for "losing" Vitters.

Of course, MLB probably would have conducted some kind of investigation if the Cubs had done that, but so what?

Actually,.I'd probably do that every year.

You've got to sign the 1st round compensation pick because you can't get another one the next year for not signing that pick, but then I'd always let my "regular" 1st round pick from the draft "get away," and instead give the money to a player (or players) picked in a later round who slip for "signability" reasons.

I'd do that with my 2nd round pick every year, too.

 

1st round Parachat?

I advertise it just for you Carlos and you ditch me...that's cool.

 

from the live blog...

Not sure on 39 but this is a well timed question. I projected this in my mock but I've just heard that Cubs would probably not pass Casey Kelly if he's available.

as I think the NCAA has a rule where someone can play pro in one sport and be an ameueter in another.

AZ Phil:

What do you think of James Russell? He's barely 22 and already pitching well at AA -- he's looking more and more like the steal and/or the best pitching talent drafted last year. If you ask me, he looks like a young Jon Lieber; solid control numbers, middle-of-the-road strikeout numbers and some problems with his homeruns allowed.

However, is his ceiling a good #3 like Lieber? Or is he more of the middle-reliever with awesome control kind?

Thanks in advance.

any chance he jumps straight to MLB? Given that Boros is his agent, he is going to get an MLB deal anyways so they might as well try him out in the bigs. I can not see him being any worse than the Baustia/Ball stealer platoon they have now.

AZ Phil,

Why the heck are you not getting paid by the Cubs for your analysis? I think we need to draft a letter to Sam Zell.

Great stuff.

by 2 feet. Anyone else with MLBTV mosaic having issues trying to get the STL/WAS game? I was hoping to watch the draft, that game and the PHI/CIN game, but the Cards game has a streaming error.

I'm here, Rob.

Wellemeyer tosses 6 shutout innings to lower his ERA under 3.00.

He posted a 3.11 with the Cards last year.

Clearly, they taught him something. Always suspicious when a mediocre pitcher suddenly "finds" his stuff after several years in the majors.

He always had Good arm/stuff. His command was his undoing. Yet another example of Dave Duncan spinning straw into gold. Cubs need to get Leo Mazzone and maybe we can stop spending 9 million dollars for #5 starters.

Take Andrew Cashner at #19. Guess Hendry was trying not to lose him after taking him in last year's draft. Anyone know if they're expecting him to come up and help right away?

Recent comments

Subscribe to Recent comments
The first 600 characters of the last 16 comments, click "View" to see rest of comment.
  • vogelbomb debut for tacoma (AAA SEA)... 3-3, 1bb, 1 HR, 1 double...DH'd.

    while he mostly played 1st considerably more than DH for AAA CHC, DJ Peterson is probably going to see most of the time at 1st for AAA SEA.

    crunch 7 hours 17 min ago view
  • Carl Jr.! Very nice!

    Baez with another "WTF?" play trying a delayed steal with a runner on 3rd and one out.. Remarkable talent, needs to make better decisions.

    billybucks 8 hours 14 min ago view
  • m.montgomery up in the pen with a man on 2nd, 2 out, and rondon 20 pitches into the inning.

    ...and rondon ends it 22 pitches in with a popout to RF.

    crunch 8 hours 24 min ago view
  • I gotta say with the crappy defense the Brewers have displayed outside of Fowler I'm pretty disappointed the offense hasn't shown more and Rizzo seems to be very swing happy lately. That said my god am I happy Madden has finally given Carl Edwards a chance after multiple times up with nothing. I don't think he could handle a starting role with his body frame but his stuff plays so well in a relief role and he seems to be able to handle high stress situations very well.

    johann 9 hours 28 min ago view
  • 2nd at bat. Fowler is good for the Cubs run differential.

    Cubster 11 hours 4 min ago view
  • welcome back fowler.

    crunch 11 hours 30 min ago view
  • More slow news...

    http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2016/07/22/cubs-albert...

    Did Davey Martinez have to bring the shotgun?

    http://www.madcoversite.com/mad104printid.jpg

    Cubster 11 hours 52 min ago view
  • glad to see almora going to AAA to get work.

    .265/.291/.422 through 86PA...2hr, 7 doubles.

    i don't expect too much of an improvement when he's taking over CF next year, but the team doesn't really need him right now as much as they need him to get regular work (imo).

    crunch 13 hours 49 min ago view
  • CHITOWNMVP01: The Cubs MLB Reserve List (40-man roster) has had one slot open since 7/6 (when RHRP Joel Peralta was Designated for Assignment). 

    Arizona Phil 14 hours 19 min ago view
  • The problem with the September roster is all of the pitching changes. They should find a way to limit pitchers to twelve except for extra inning games. More pinch hitters or pinch runners do little to slow the game down and are more fun than endless calls to the bullpen. I also think the fans get cheated when they use position players to pitch because employed a half dozen pitchers with righty-lefty switches. Having as few as four positions players on the bench to start a game also leads to some pretty ugly defensive substitutions.

    Non Roster Invitee 14 hours 31 min ago view
  • CHITOWNMVP01: Joe Nathan's 30-day Article XIX-C minor league rehab assignment expires tomorrow, but he doesn't have to be reinstated from the 60-day DL tomorrow. 

    Arizona Phil 14 hours 34 min ago view
  • Also, I think 40 man roster should be full, not at 39, unless I counted wrong. I'm in a hurry to leave the house.

    chitownmvp01 14 hours 37 min ago view
  • Dexter Fowler is back! "You go, we go!"

    He's being activated for tonight's game. Almora down and Montgomery replaces Patton.

    http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/17126605/chicago...

    Also, doesn't Nathan have to be activated tomorrow? Pitchers aren't allowed to spend more than 30 days of rehab and he was sent to rehab assignment on June 23rd. Tomorrow is July 23rd.

    chitownmvp01 14 hours 45 min ago view
  • Yeah, last night was a bummer. I clicked on the espn Gamecast just in time to see the 5-2 score change to 5-5.

    Their next 10 are Dodgers, Mets and Marlins.

    billybucks 17 hours 29 min ago view
  • Arizona Phil 18 hours 9 min ago view
  • Cubster 18 hours 13 min ago view