Home Run Howry

I'm a relatively patient person - a dog, twin 3-year old daughters, the Angel-fan wife and being a Cubs fan do that to a person. But the antics of Bob Howry have grown tiresome. And yeah, I'm probably the last on that bandwagon (see above about being patient).I mean, he was good for us in 2006 and 2007. Not great, but good; as he posted ERA's of 3.17 and 3.32, along with respectable win probabilty added scores of 0.93 and 1.73. So I think some of that patience was warranted - unfortunately so does manager Lou Piniella.

Lou's consistent reliance on Howry out there in crucial situations, even with a depleted bullpen of late, is near Dusty-level stupid. The decision to let Bob Howry pitch to notorious Cub-killer Carlos Lee with first base open yesterday, is Andy McPhail-stupid.

Let's take a look at what could be troubling Howry...

 Season ERA
 2005 2.47 5.92 1.97 0.49 .222  4.7%
 2006 3.17 8.33 2.00 0.94 .299  8.3%
 2007 3.32 7.97 2.10 0.89 .302  7.0%
 2008 5.09 6.96 1.36 1.70 .336  11.6%

 A few points of reference for some of the less numbers-inclined, average is considered around .300 for BABIP (Batting Average in Balls in Play). When you see something in the .222 range like Howry's 2005 season, expect it go up the next season (in most cases) and the ERA to follow, as did Howry in 2005. Most pitchers give up homers on around 10% of the flyballs they give up (HR/FB%) and the same corollary applies. Now, it's in my opinion that the peripheral stats of a reliever tend to look better than the norm in most cases. For example, take a look at the leaderboard on ESPN for strikeout rates with at least 40 innings pitched and you'll find 10 relievers with at least a 10 or more strikeouts per nine innings and just one starter. So the 8.3% and 7.0% of home runs that flew out of the park the last two years are pretty much right in line with Howry's career mark and didn't call for too much of a correction.

Back to the chart o' numbers and there's a few things that stick out about Howry's 2008 season to date. His strikeout rate has been declining steadily now for a few years and is down to 6.96 for 2008. He thrived in 2005 with an even lower strikeout rate, but that seems due to a healthy dose of luck. Now his walk rate has also gone down as well this year, so it might be a bit of gaining control while sacrificing velocity (spoiler: he hasn't). Of course, it appears he's sacrificing getting batters out as well, as evidenced by the skyrocketing ERA, BABIP and home run rates. It's a bit of a chicken and the egg theory going on here, is Howry just being unlucky at times as evidenced by his BABIP and HR/FB% rates this year, or is he losing some of "stuff' and getting pounded accordingly, hence the reason for the rise in his ERA and peripheral numbers.

I took a dip into the Pitch F/x waters to see if I could spot anything that might indicate Howry has lost something on his pitches (and I profess I'm a newbie at analyzing the Pitch f/x data). As Transmission pointed out earlier this year, Howry averaged 92.3 mph on his fastball last season, but that was only measured for games played at Wrigley. I believe the Pitch F/x system has been installed in all parks for 2008 and Howry's average fastball velocity has taken a very small dip to 91.2 mph on average (according to Fangraphs).  The 2008 player card by Josh Kalk shows an average of 92.14 on his fastball, so I think it's safe to say his velocity is about the same. I did notice on the Fangraphs info that he's throwing quite a quite a few more sliders this year, up from 9.7% of his pitches(that were actually tracked) to 22.7% this year. You then combine that with the info at Inside Edge scouting report that shows his slider is getting whacked for a .353 batting average(out of games scouted) and you start to piece together that Howry may be getting away from his bread and butter of pounding the outside of the plate with his fastball. 

The numbers also indicate why Lou seems to keep giving him a chance. His "stuff" still seems to be there for the most part. And we know Lou's preference for pitchers, particularly relievers, that don't walk batters. And for all the troubles of Howry, he's making the other team earn it for the most part. But at some point, Lou's going to give up on faith and take a look that Howry just can't get anyone out right now. Of course, it's going to help that Kerry Wood is back and Carlos Marmol can go back to being the main set-up man. The shutdown bullpen of Howry in the 7th, Marmol in the 8th and Wood in the 9th, never really materialized this season and I do hope that Howry is pushed way back on the depth chart and Chad Gaudin and Jeff Samardzija are given his late-inning opportunities.


Well done, Rob. Possible Lou is giving Howry a chance to straighten himself out before he has to make a hard decision and drop him or push him to the back of the bullpen as we get to the real grind of the pennant race? In any case, it's nice having Gaudin and Samardzija to turn to if Howry is done.


I should learn to read more completely before I comment since what I wrote is exactly what you wrote at the end of the post, Rob.

I can only conclude that you and I are both geniuses. 

How can anyone disagree with this thesis? The man's been given numerous chances to right himself, yet neither Lou nor (hello!) Rothschild can straighten him out at this point. We're in a pennant race, no more opportunites unless it's a blow - out (and I mean a huge blow - out).

Great breakdown on Howry. What happens with Lieber gets ready to come back? Do you send down Samardzija? Or do you DFA Howry? Or DFA Lieber?

I'd like to see more of Samardzija before declaring him trustworthy in the bullpen. I would probably DFA Lieber, because maybe Howry can turn it around, but I think Lieber is probably just about cooked.

send Marshall down, he's not doing much and he'll be back by September

Let's get the Gooz up here, ASAP.

How is he doing? Will he finally be out of options next season, or do we get yet another extension? If Guzman turns into a good relief pitcher, what a bonus on a guy we all wrote off.

I believe he is out of options, but the Cubs do have control over him for one more year. As for his rehab, the minors page at BR.com shows one game started, two innings, one earned run (three overall), 2 K's, 0 BB's at Hi-A Daytona. Before he left Daytona, AZ Phil said he was looking pretty good down at Fitch Park. 

pretty good shot to be a Sept call-up...

The Cubs are #2

"Although Bob Howry's overall numbers aren't pretty, manager Lou Piniella keeps running him out there. Howry has a 5.30 ERA, but he's stranded 21 of 24 inherited runners."


I respectfully disagree with Crasnick's rankings. 

And yeah, Howry came in and shut the door yesterday in the 6th stranding some inherited runners and then shit his pants in the 7th. 

But he wasn't sliding into home!

Karstens in Arizona through 7.1 IP

made it to 7.2 IP and then gave up a double to Chris Young....

a walk, a double play, a single to Drew in the 9th...29 hitters.

Well, who you gonna believe, Crasnick or your lyin' eyes?

goes 2 for 4 in his major league debut with a homer for the O's.

Way to go kid...

You may remember several posts I made last year discussing the fact that Howry had, in the second half of last year, almost entirely junked his slider and was relying nearly exclusively on fastballs and that, moreover, his decision to do so seemed to coincide largely with greater effectiveness in the second half. That he was able to be as succesful as he was last year in the second half was largely due, in my view, to his ability to locate the fastball.

I am troubled by his increased reliance on the slider (as the graph shows), although I have not seen it personally. It's not a great pitch for him; it doesn't break a lot, he has a tendency to hang it and he doesn't have great command over it. What is more a problem is that he doesn't seem to be locating the fastball as well as he did last year. I think the velocity is still there, but the location doesn't seem to be.

Howry seems to be a stand-up guy and a competitor, which is why he has been somewhat of a favorite of mine. When he pitches well, he executes pitching strategies pretty well (climbing the ladder, etc.) He does not "give in" to hitters. He does not walk a lot of people. That said, his repertoire is pretty simple. He throws one fastball (4-seam), has no changeup and his slider (his only breaking pitch) is weak. He needs to be pretty fine with his location on the fastball in order to be at all effective.

sounds familiar, and you sure seem to be on to something...

I do believe he does have a change that he uses as often as Rich Hill uses his. His charts show him using one about 4% of the time.  

It's NOT.

This was Howry a year ago today vs the middle of the Astros order according to MLB Gameday:

1] 96 mph, 95, 94
2] 95,95,95,95,95
3] 95,95,95,96
inning over

every pitch was a fastball

This was Howry in the 7th yesterday vs the Astros:

1]92,slider **single**
3]slider, slider, 93,93, slider, slider, slider
coaching visit to mound
4]92 **Carlos Lee HR**
5]slider, slider, slider
inning over

6 fastballs, 9 sliders


MLB gameday uses the same pitch f/x data that I used and the averages were about the same. I didn't study each of his individual games though or any time periods.

It's certainly possible that he was hitting mid 90's for a time last year. It's possible he was hitting it for a time this year  as well though. 


I think the velocity is OK. Howry does not have a 98 mph heater or one with a lot of movement. People with that kind of stuff can get away a lot of the time by just throwing it in the strike zone someplace. He's not in that category.

Off topic, but never too early to review upcoming schedules.

As of right now, each of the Cubs, Cardinals and Brewers has 47 games left (the Cardinals have a night game tonight). Here’s how they break out:


Home 23
Away 24

Games against teams with a .500 (or better) winning percentage: 26 (9 STL, 6 MIL, 3 FL, 4 PHI, 4 NY)

Games against teams with a less than .500 winning percentage: 21 (3 ATL, 6 CIN, 3WAS, 3 PIT, 6 HOU)


Home 22
Away 25

Games against teams with a .500 (or better) winning percentage: 27 (2 MIL, 2 LA, 9 CUBS, 7 FLA, 7 AZ)

Games against teams with a less than .500 winning percentage: 20 (9 CIN, 3 ATL, 5 PIT, 3 HOU)


Home 26
Away 21

Games against teams with a .500 (or better) winning percentage: 18 (2 STL, 3 LA, 6 CUBS, 3 NY, 4 PHI)

Games against teams with a less than .500 winning percentage: 29 (4 WAS, 7 SDG, 9 PIT, 6 CIN, 3 HOU)

The schedule favors the Brewers in a fairly major way at this point. The Cardinals’ schedule is slightly tougher than the Cubs’. Of course, the big thing will be the head to head between the three teams. The Cardinals and the Brewers play each other only twice more this season. The Cardinals and Cubs play 9 times and the Brewers and Cubs play 6 times. Put another way, slightly less than a third of the Cubs’ remaining games are against Milwaukee and St. Louis.

At this point, I think it will take at least 95 wins to win the division. I like where Chicago sits, but the Brewers could make a lot of hay playing the Nationals and Padres 11 times from here on out.

If the Cubs can take care of business in their games against St. Louis and Milwaukee (play .500 or better, say 8 wins), and win 12 of their 21 against below .500 teams, that would get them to 89 wins. Then they would need to take 6 of 11 from the Marlins, Phillies and Mets to get to 95.

If the Brewers play .500 against the Cubs, that would get them to 67 wins. If they cleaned up against the below .500 teams (say .700 winning percentage, or 21 wins) that would get them to 88 wins. They would then need to win 7 out of 12 against the other .500 or better teams (STL, NY, PHI and LA, which is, incidentally, exactly .500 as of now) to get to 95.

The Cardinals’ road is much tougher, with 7 games each against Florida and Arizona. Also, their below .500 teams don’t include San Diego (.381) or the Nats (.372), like the Brewers (who have 7 games against the Padres). If they split against the Cubs (say 5 wins), that would get them to 68 wins. If they won 14 of 20 against the below .500 teams, that would get them 82 wins. They would then need to win 13 out of 18 against Milwaukee, Los Angeles, Florida and Arizona to get to 95.

Dodgers ain't helping -- about to lose their 2nd straight to Cards. Cards absolutely pummeled Lowe tonight.

If the Cubs can keep winning series after series, I'll stop scoreboard watching.

Okay, no I won't. Who am I kidding?

And while he has become the newest target of Wrigley Field boo birds, Howry has the manager's backing.

"Bob works hard and I have confidence in him," Piniella said. "I keep bringing him in there and I'll continue to do so.

"The home run ball has hurt [him]. Maybe he's just in a little bit of an unfortunate streak, but he gives you everything he has. I expect him to have a pretty good finish."


Uh-oh. Don't like the sound of that.

"Bob works hard and I have confidence in himhe has naked pictures of me," Piniella said. "I keep bringing him in there and I'll continue to do so.

Fixed it for ya, Lou.

Pinhead's Dustiness coming out. Apparently you just have to work hard, not actually be good to get into Lou's good graces. So now we know the difference between Eyre and Howry. I wonder if it all boiled down to Eyre's shin splints issue. 'What? He doesn't run? Well he better be good or he's not going to pitch.'

On Howry's pitching I don't really see the great command that his low BB rate implies. If you lose a bit of control, you tend to aim more for the heart of the strike zone if you want to keep your walk numbers down. If you do that, you also tend to give up more home runs.

Howry's slider moves so little, that I don't even recognize it. When I see the 84 MPH pitches come in, I was assuming they were change-ups.

somewhere along the line howry and wuertz both forgot how to keep their control in the zone low. howry's slider has never been a big control pitch for him, but when he can locate his fastball low in/away he can junk over a slider every once in a while and use that effectively.

im not gonna get into the "why is he throwing so many more sliders" thing...some people wanna blame the catcher, rothschild, howry, the pope, whatever. there's gotta be a reason he's throwing so many sliders. maybe that's what he's doing when his velocity isn't there that day. i mean, his fastball isn't THAT good even when it's 100% there.

one thing i have noticed about howry is his velocity doesn't hold up over multiple starts like it used to.

he used to come out and boom...93-95mph easy. 3-5 times a week, no prob.

now it seems like he's doing a lot of 91-93mph work on days following 94+mph outtings.


Whatever the reason, he's not getting beat on bloopers and dribblers. These things are rockets. When that many hitters are hammering the ball, it's time to move out of the late inning role for a while.

s.gallagher to miss his next start due to shoulder soreness...they're not going to DL him, though...for now, anyway.

Coery update:

Now hitting .191 after an 0-for-4 yeserday, which is an improvement over his .183 at July 30.

Dude, that sucks, big time.

Recent comments

Subscribe to Recent comments
The first 600 characters of the last 16 comments, click "View" to see rest of comment.
  • Thank you PHIL.

    Glad you avoided temps in the 100s.

    I remember you mentioning Dewees needng plenty of work in th IF. How are his OF instincts?

    Also, did see much of Satchel McElroy? Only Satchel I have heard about other than the "orignal" and one of Woody Allen's kids.

    The E-Man 1 hour 47 min ago view
  • Hate to give the Mets credit, but they did everything right tonight in what had to be a very tough game for them to play. As Hollandsworth said on the Cubs post-game -- if you watched the game, you saw Mets players consoling Marlins players who were in tears during the game. Between that and the way Molina handled the Ross farewell -- maybe the Mets and Cardinal players aren't pure evil. Just the fans.

    billybucks 9 hours 18 min ago view
  • New York Mets @Mets
    Dee Gordon lead-off home run. #AintEvenMad #BiggerThanBaseball 1-0 Miami.
    7:25 PM - 26 Sep 2016


    crunch 9 hours 56 min ago view
  • Amazing effort by Gordon -- truly remarkable.

    billybucks 10 hours 17 min ago view
  • Cubs get 100, KB gets 100, Hendricks gets below 2.00, Cards get absolutely destroyed by the Reds -- all good, other than some Rondon concern. Hopefully, he can get a few outings in this week and find his groove. Also, I guess Soler is still struggling with his right side. Hmmmm. Too bad Joe didn't let Addy bat with the bases loaded in the 7th -- great RBI opportunity.

    I assume all the relievers are on a set schedule this week, but it seems strange Chapman pitched back-to-back.

    billybucks 10 hours 19 min ago view
  • Barry Rozner article interviewing Greg Maddux (with comments on Kyle Hendricks).


    "I like watching him pitch," Maddux said of Hendricks. "I like guys that rely on movement and location. I can relate to him. That's what I had to do. "I'd rather watch him pitch than some lefty throwing 95 mph."

    Cubster 10 hours 40 min ago view
  • cubs win #100. neat.

    crunch 10 hours 48 min ago view
  • Chapman in to stop the bleeding.

    Brick 10 hours 56 min ago view
  • they're falling apart late in WAS...damn.

    crunch 11 hours 27 min ago view
  • Wilson Ramos may be hurt badly. Carried off the field. Looks like the knee.

    John Beasley 11 hours 29 min ago view
  • Hendricks 6 shutout innings, ends night with an ERA of 1.99

    Cubster 11 hours 40 min ago view
  • in case it hasn't been mentioned yet, Twins are hiring Indians 32-year old Derick Falvey from the Cleveland Native Americans organization.

    Suppose McLeod could still be asked by another organization but likely staying put.

    Rob G. 12 hours 38 min ago view
  • Well put, both your remark, and Crunch's.

    Transmission 12 hours 39 min ago view
  • I saw the Gordon HR. It was like a funeral where the mourners were made to play baseball. So sad...

    CTSteve 12 hours 44 min ago view
  • i wanted to watch more of it, but it started to feel like i was going beyond witnessing a human experience that isn't often seen into an uncomfortable voyeurism. these guys are in pain.

    crunch 13 hours 3 min ago view
  • wow I am glad I missed the start of the MIA game.  I would have been sobbing.

    Transmission 13 hours 12 min ago view