Room for One More: The Rule 29 Draft

No time like the holiday season to be grateful for what we have... and to keep in mind that there is always... Room for One More... 

Most of you are familar with the Rule 5 Draft, held the last day of the MLB Winter Meetings every year, where MLB clubs can select players off minor league rosters. The Cubs lost Donald Veal in the Major League Phase of the draft just last week.

And then there's the Rule 4 Draft (formerly known as the "Amateur Draft" and now known as the "1st Year Player Draft") held in June, where MLB clubs select high school and college players. RHP Andrew Cashner (TCU) was the Cubs #1 pick in last June's Rule 4 Draft.

Less well-known and more rarely held is the MLB Expansion Draft, used in 1960-61, 1968, 1976, 1992, and 1997 to distribute major league talent to expansion teams like the New York Mets, Kansas City Royals, Toronto Blue Jays, and Florida Marlins, as they joined the American League or National League  Over the years, the Cubs have lost guys like Don Zimmer, Dick Drott, John Boccabella, Bill Stoneman, Joe Girardi, and Miguel Cairo in various expansion drafts.    

But there is one MLB draft that has never been held.  

In the event that an incident occurs where at least five players from the same MLB club are killed, dismembered, or permanently disabled during the season, MLB has a "Rehabilitation Plan" in place under Rule 29 that includes financial support and a "Restocking Draft" for the stricken club. The plan has existed in basically the same form since 1965, so the method for allocating talent to the affected team essentially follows the mechanism used to distribute players to MLB expansion teams in 1960-61.    

Under this plan, after a reasonable period of mourning, and presuming that the Commissioner and MLBPA jointly agree that the club's season should continue, each of the other 29 clubs would be required to contribute five players (including at least one pitcher, one infielder, and one outfielder, and one catcher if the club is carrying at least three catchers) from its Active List (25-man roster) into a pool of players, and from this pool, the club that suffered the loss would be allowed to select replacements for the players lost in the disaster. . 

No club would lose more than one player, and any player with a "no trade" right would be exempt from inclusion in the pool. The five players made available by each club would have to include as many players with a minimum of 60+ days of MLB service time as were lost in the disaster. Players on the Disabled List can't be included in the pool unless the club certifies that the player is healthy enough to be immediately reactivated if selected.

So if a disaster had occurred sometime last season and Rule 29 had been invoked, the Cubs probably would have placed the likes of Ronny Cedeno, Daryle Ward, Jon Lieber, Scott Eyre, and Bob Howry in the pool. Fortunately, the MLB Rehabilitation Plan (and the Restocking Draft) has never been needed, but considering the number of airplane flights taken by clubs every year, MLB has been lucky (so far).

Some fans might recall the tragic losses over the years of several members (or even entire squads) of various sports teams, including the U. S. Olympic Figure Skating team, the Cal Poly, Marshall University and Wichita State football teams, the University of Evansville basketball team, the U. S. Amateur Boxing team, and various international soccer teams, in plane crashes, and certainly there is also always the possibility of a hotel fire or bus crash or terrorist attack that could kill or maim scores (including members of a sports team).

While individual major leaguers have died during the season in a car crash (Josh Hancock) or a plane crash (Thurman Munson), or have been shot to death (Lyman Bostock), or fell off a bridge at Niagara Falls (Ed Delahanty), an entire team has never been lost.

Eight members of the minor league Spokane Indians were killed and one was critically injured in a fiery bus crash in 1946, but the only time more than one MLB player has been killed in the same incident was during Spring Training 1993, when two members of the Cleveland Indians (pitchers Steve Olin and Tim Crews) were killed in a boating accident in Florida (a third player--veteran LHP Bob Ojeda--was seriously injured).   

The NFL (if 15 or more players from the same club are killed or permanently disabled in a single incident during the season), the NBA (if five or more players from the same team are killed or permanently disabled in an incident during the season), and the NHL (also if five or more players from the same team are killed or permanently disabled) also have plans in place for restocking affected clubs in the event of a common disaster, but hopefully the plans will continue to remain just theoretical contingencies. 


Interesting article. I hope no one tells Jim Bowden about this.

It's only funny because it's true.

What has this got to do with Jake Peavy?

"So if a disaster had occurred sometime last season and Rule 29 had been invoked, the Cubs probably would have placed the likes of Ronny Cedeno, Daryle Ward, Jon Lieber, Scott Eyre, and Bob Howry in the pool."

For the team that had suffered the airplane crash or other calamity and had to pick from that lot, I believe this would amount to compounding the tragedy.

Fascinating piece, AZ Phil.

Great, creepy little story in that article. That might explain the nervous, freaked-out look on the face of Ronny Cedeno. Perhaps he has a recurring "Room for one more, sir" nightmare that has kept him permanently distracted on the baseball field, causing numerous lapses as he constantly looks over his shoulder for the ominous figure from his dream.

Jack Wilson thinks the Pirates need more players to be competitive in 2009. I was going to say they need better players, but more players in general might help them, too. Maybe a 24-man bullpen would allow the manager to start situationally pitching in the first inning.

If they could load up on Black and Latin players. Then I'd think they would perform much better during the dog days of summer.

Just Sayin

Why Paul Bako over Hank White?


But why Paul Bako over Koyie Hill?

Good looks.

Number of fingers was in the final decision process

I see. I now understand why the Cubs acquired Antonio Alfonseca a few years ago.

it was brought up earlier by someone else that felix pie wasn't playing which i countered with "he is playing, but not as much recently"...along with a slower DEC. schedule with more days off and a rainout.

well, things are still slow with days off, but pie is seeing almost no starts and mostly PH/late-inning replacement work. he last saw a game on sunday (2 days off between then and now), but that was only for pinch hit work.

is he just hanging with family? hurt? just slowing down for the season?

mid+NOV gets confusing on a lot of these latin (non-AZ/HI teams) because they tend to open up the rosters or play players that weren't playing earlier...felix pie was "late" to winter ball, himself.

I know the consensus is pretty much that it's lights out/case closed for Pie with the Cubs, but I can't help but think that maybe he's playing a bit too MUCH baseball. Hasn't he been playing winter ball for, like, the last 15 years or so?

I think Pie needs to play year-round till he learns how to hit. Carlos Marmol, on the other hand, has nothing to prove, and there he was pitching an inning for Licey the other day. I can't imagine that the Cubs are happy about him not taking the months off.

From Marmol's point of view, a) it's fun to play near home, and b) the Cubs don't pay me enough.

Recent comments

Subscribe to Recent comments
The first 600 characters of the last 16 comments, click "View" to see rest of comment.
  • video of Maddon.

    always nice that he actually tries to honestly answer questions. Does mention that he wanted to give Zastr? a chance in a meaningful spot rather than a mop-up role.

    Rob G. 3 hours 5 min ago view
  • from Muskat:

    #Cubs Maddon: "I'm not going to make up an excuse for why I did what I did. It has nothing to do with lack of confidence" ... "It was the right thing to do today based on what I saw, what their lineup looked like and Rob Z.'s availability." #Cubs

    Rob G. 3 hours 11 min ago view

    Hammel not particularly understanding of getting pulled he should. Be curious what Maddon had to say. All I can think of is is keeping arms fresh and maybe wanting to see if Zastr? is worth considering for the playoffs and how he'd do against the Dodgers.

    Rob G. 3 hours 16 min ago view
  • great defense

    Heyward, Russell, Baez, Bryant, Ross in particular...although Bryant's a bit hard to judge with all the positions.

    Fowler and Rizzo in the top half of the NL for their positions as well (per fangraphs)...Zobrist right at the halfway cutoff for 2b in the NL.

    I'm sure some luck is involved too, but the Cubs and Maddon knew what they were doing.

    Rob G. 3 hours 27 min ago view
  • If all the starters have FIP > ERA, is that luck or good defense?

    Craig A. 3 hours 39 min ago view
  • #Cubs plummet to 19-5 in August.

    Fun with FIP

    • J. Hammel   3.07 ERA/4.27 FIP (3.68 FIP last year)
    • J. Arrieta     2.62 ERA/3.05 FIP (2.35 FIP last year)
    • J. Lester     2.81 ERA/3.67 FIP (2.92 FIP last year)
    • K. Hendricks  2.19 ERA/3.37 FIP (3.36 FIP last year)
    • J. Lackey     3.41 ERA/3.72 FIP (3.57 FIP last year with Cards)
    Rob G. 4 hours 4 min ago view
  • zastyryzryzryzny put in 3.2ip 1h 0bb 3k

    he's great when his control is "on"...problem is it's rarely "on" consistently. he could vault up the cubs prospect list if he ever gets better with that aspect of his game.

    crunch 4 hours 44 min ago view
  • JD's take was just trying to get in a lefty to better deal with mostly lefty Dodgers lineup.

    My second thought was what you came up with. My first thought was he was trying to light a fire under Hammel.

    Jackstraw 5 hours 56 min ago view
  • Maybe he was trying to spare him another brutal road start? NY, Colorado...

    billybucks 6 hours 13 min ago view
  • joe got a pitcher up for hammel at nearly the 1st sign of trouble in the 3rd...pulled after 2.1

    not injured and though it wasn't his day so far he wasn't looking like a pure disaster.

    really short leash on him. zastryznzryzryny in.

    crunch 6 hours 17 min ago view
  • Russell and Soler can attest that Urias has a pretty good curve/slider - two big strikeouts looking to get out of that jam in the first.

    Eric S 7 hours 2 min ago view
  • Classic Scully - great stuff.

    Thank God we'll still have Hawk next season. (cricket cricket cricket)

    Eric S 11 hours 53 min ago view
  • Here's Scully's call on Bryant's 10th-inning homer:

    "And it's a long fly ball, a mean fly ball, and a gone fly ball."

    VirginiaPhil 13 hours 7 min ago view
  • When the Cubs were the old, hundred-year Cubs, one bad hop did not undo their opponents.

    VirginiaPhil 13 hours 10 min ago view
  • If only he was clutcher. More clutcher.

    Jackstraw 14 hours 29 min ago view
  • cubs win...bryant with 7HR in his last 8 games.

    crunch 21 hours 41 min ago view