Cub Bats Go Silent at Talking Stick

Five Colorado pitchers combined to throw a five-hit shutout, and Jordan Pacheco crushed a pinch-hit three-run home run, leading a Rockies split squad to a 4-0 whitewashing of the Cubs in afternoon Cactus League action at Salt River Fields at Talking Stick Resort on Salt River Maricopa-Pima Indian Community land located east of Scottsdale today.

box score

The Cubs got their lead-off hitter on base in four separate  innings, but could not get the big hit when they needed it.

Geovany Soto reached on a ground rule (fan interference) double leading off the top of the second, but failed to advance to third on a ground-out bouncer over the pitcher's head that would have allowed him to score on another ground out later in the inning.

Starlin Castro singled to lead-off the 4th, but was left stranded at 1st base when the next three Cubs hitters went down in order. (And Castro was totally perplexed by Rockies LHP Jorge De La Rosa's delivery, to the extent that he kept returning to 1st base every time De La Rosa threw the ball home).

Facing RHP Clay Mortensen, Kosuke Fukudome walked to lead-off the top of the 5th, and then Blake DeWitt followed with a line-drive single to right-center that sent Kosuke scampering to 3rd. But Scott Moore and PH Max Ramirez both struck out swinging (although M. Ramirez launched a 400-ft foul ball that drifted just outside the LF foul pole), and Fernando Perez grounded out sharply to 3rd (nice diving stop & throw by Rockies 3B Thomas Field, who robbed Perez of an RBI).  

And finally Jim Adduci led off the 8th with a pinch-hit single up through the box (deflected by the pitcher), but Reed Johnson popped out, Matt Camp struck out, and Lou Montanez popped out to end the inning. 

Bobby Scales also singled with two outs in the 7th.

And that was the extent of the Cubs offense.   

Carlos Zambrano was the Cubs starting pitcher today, and he labored through his three innings. Although he worked fast and didn't walk anybody, he did throw 61 pitches (41 for strikes), including a 25-pitch 1st inning. He allowed one run (earned) on five hits (all singles), but one of the hits was a pop-up to LF that Tyler Colvin misplayed into a single. (Colvin initially broke back, then tried to recover, spinning his wheels as he tried to go forward, as the ball dropped safely in front of him). Colvin has struggled with his outfield defense throughout Spring Training.

While Zambrano did not allow any extra base hits and none of the singles he surrendered were hit particulary hard, he only had one strikeout (he couldn't put hitters away once he got two strikes, as the Rockies hitters kept fouling balls off) and he had trouble keeping the ball down, the second time in a row this has happened. It almost looks like he is either short-arming the ball (even more than usual), or maybe his back is bothering him. But he doesn't look quite right.   

Sean Marshall threw a shutout 4th inning and looked good, except he essentially needed to get four outs because the Cubs infield once again could not turn a routine 6-4-3 DP. (Blake DeWitt's relay throw to 1st was off-line, and 1B Scott Moore missed the batter-runner with the tag). 

Veteran RHP Braden Looper (battling for the 5th starter's job) was next, and he breezed through the 5th & 6th (16 pitches total - 12 strikes), retiring all six men he faced. But then it was as if he hit a wall when he came out to pitch his third inning (the bottom of the 7th), as he was unable to throw strikes, could not control his breaking ball, and lost some velocity on his fastball. It was this inning where (off Looper) Rockies PH Jordan Pacheco hammered his three-run jack. For the day Looper threw 35 pitches (20 strikes), but it looks like if he throws anything more than about 15-20 pitches, he's gassed.  

Burly RHP Robert Coello (recently acquired from the Boston Red Sox for minor league 2B Tony Thomas) pitched the 8th inning, and once again he had absolutely nasty stuff, was almost impossible to hit (he racked up two strikeouts), and he had a lot of trouble throwing strikes (24 pitches - 14 strikes in 1.0 IP). He did throw seven straight strikes after receiving a visit to the mound from new Cubs pitching coach Mark Riggins, however.

Today was my first time inside Salt River Fields (it just opened last month), and it is a magnificent faciility conveniently located between two freeway off-ramps. The main stadium is very nice (comfortable chair-seats, informative scoreboard, steeply-sloped outfield lawn seating, concession stands with grills, rest rooms located right behind the grand stand, and lots of shaded seating). The grounds are shared by the Colorado Rockies and the Arizona Diamondbacks (both teams moved their Spring Training operation and Minor League HQ up to Maricopa County from Tucson after last season), with the Rockies practice fields, ticket office, and clubhouse located on the south end of the property, and the D'backs' fields, ticket office, and clubhouse on the north side. Each team's roomy two-story clubhouse includes a fitness center and plenty of office space and meeting rooms. The two teams share the main stadium (one team is home each day). Each side of the shared complex features ten batting cages, four full fields, and a half-field that can be used for bunting drills, baserunning instruction, and Pitchers Fielding Practice. Elevated walkways have been constructed above and next to the batting cages and back fields, providing outstanding views for the fans. 

Most all of the Cub brass was at today's game and gave the facility a close inspection, probably to help gather some ideas for the new Cubs Spring Training & Minor League complex that will be constructed at Riverview Park in Mesa (at 8th Street & Dobson Road) over the next couple of years.      


Your hunch. Coello late reliever in Iowa or makes it to Wrigley in April?

Submitted by tim815 on Tue, 03/08/2011 - 8:33pm.
Your hunch. Coello late reliever in Iowa or makes it to Wrigley in April?


TIM: Right now I would guess Coello goes to Iowa out of Spring Training.

As AZ PHIL has been giving nice updates, including those on Vitter's progress (or lack thereof), he mentioned recently that it is possible that A-Ram might just end up with the Cubs again next year.

Of course a lot of this depends on how both the above players do this year.

I was curious who was a free agent next year in case Vitters does not pan out, and the Cubs do not have any viable internal candidate.

Here is the list of 3B via MLB Trade Rumors:

It is truly the "Old Man's Club".

Blech. I hope Vitters can get his shit together or another player can rise to the occasion. If not, we are potentially looking at another post-Santo to prime A-Ram era again.

The Cubs actually found a great replacement for Santo only a few years after he left but Bill Madlock had the misfortune of being black while asking PK Wrigley to pay him like the batting champ he was.

Then traded Madlock for Bobby Murcer and paid him more than Madlock was asking for. PK was a douche.


Yeah, that was when cynicism first started to make inroads on my attitude about the Cubs' ownership. My first experience of rampant executive stupidity, soon to be followed by the Maddux non-signing debacle. The Maddux thing, combined with the '94 strike, put me off following the Cubs (and baseball) for a good 7 years. Ugh.

Interesting article in that it's hard to tell if Quade or Zambrano does more heroin.

Headline:"Perez's speed an asset to Cubs"

okay, dazzle me with how this will help the cubs win games and how the lack of it has hurt the team recently.

The Chicago Cubs and the San Francisco Giants tied for the fewest stolen bases in the Major Leagues last season with 55.

well that's a poor start...

The last real base-running threat that the Cubs featured in their lineup was outfielder Juan Pierre during the 2006 season. That season, Pierre stole 58 bases for a horrendous North Side team that Dusty Baker managed to 96 losses.

Fantastic, point out that when they did have a stealing threat, they still sucked. I feel Levine didn't do very well in debate club in high school.

further down...

Since 2000, the Cubs have had only three players steal more than 30 bases in a season (Eric Young had 54 in 2000, Corey Patterson stole 32 in 2004 and Pierre’s 2006 season.)

Well if you're goal was to convince me that a basestealing threat does very little to help the team win, by all means, job well done.

Lollercoasters. Well done, Rob.

That reminds me of when I edit ESL 'argument' papers for friends.

"This is what I I'll throw in whatever information I can find even if it disproves my argument".

I'm no debater but it seems to me that Perez might have won a game with his speed just this past Monday.

Perez walked with one out in the ninth, stole second, took third on a fly to center and scored on a two-out single.

Statistically, it would be hard to prove who or what won the game. Possibly it was someone who saw a lot of pitches in an at-bat in the fifth inning. But after Perez scored, the game was over and the Cubs were ahead.

how bad Vince Naimoli was as an owner

One of the Devil Rays' biggest Naimolified public relations disasters involved the St. Petersburg High School band. The team invited the band to perform the national anthem—only to have the appearance canceled after band members were told at the last minute they would have to pay to get into the ballpark.

talks about how Naimoli thought email was a fad and refused to buy it for the Rays as well..

Former Cubbie Luis Salazar hurt by a foul ball.

I hope he's going to be OK.

Lu-is Sal-a-zar (feliz navidad)
Lu-IS Sal-a-zar (feliz navidad)

Wow.. Horribly bad incident. I wonder if that might screw up McCann's (batter of the ball that struck Salazar) psyche for awhile. That could mess with your mind.

BB, BB, 1B, K, BB (Francouer of all people), 3B, 1B

K and a groundout to get out of it, 5 runs total.

23 pitches, 11 strikes, 12 balls, allegedly throwing mostly fastballs

I'm listening to the Royals crew. It sounded like he was trying to make the fastball work, even though the batters were missing the curveball by 1+ foot. I don't think Cabrera would have seen a fastball at that situation during a regular game.

Spring training ... it's just like baseball!

FYI: I heard Levine this am. He specifically reported that Garza told him he will not be throwing ANY curves today at all. It is part of his ST regimen - as he works up to it.

Garza told Levine he would be working on locating his fastball, etc.

Obviously he still needs more work at it!

Mo (Chicago)
Hey Bruce, I know he's not throwing breaking balls yet, but geesh. Should we be concerned about Garza at all? Thanks!

Bruce Levine (1:02 PM)
Good news is he started to throw breaking balls yesterday after he walked the ballpark with his fastball. And they were pretty good. Couple really good sliders. Nothing wrong with his arm, so I expect improvement from him here on out.

not as awesome as this dude

Hey love the chat! why hasn't Matt Garza lived up to expectations?

to quote Allen Iverson

"we’re talking about practice man, we’re not even talking about the game, when it actually matters, we’re talking about practice "

better 2nd inning

K, BB, FO-8, GO 6-4

GO 5-3, K, 1B and Garza is done

J. Jackson comes in and gives up a single and the inherited run

garza - 2.2ip 4h 6er 4bb 4k


maybe silva will send him a text message telling him it's okay.

Ramirez in to catch Marmol. Koyie Haters rejoice.

on what planet does that have anything to do with me or what i posted about garza?

you forgot to take your "meds".

oh, it's another immature and stupid as hell internet day for you.

your mom wears combat boots and stuff.


I think he was just replying to the general game thread that started there...

the real good part starts around :45

i just should have posted my table-cat again. it didn't get any props the last time. i desire props for table cat.

I wish to see table cat.

ah, not as good as middle finger dude, but nice

I couldn't tell what it was the first time, sort of like one of those 3D images you stare at at the mall.

yeah, it can look flunky if not viewed in Firefox (which it's optimized for).

woo...optimized bullcrap.

I also loved table cat. I didn't remember that you authored the middle fingers. I sent that around at work as an email signature for a bit with hilarious results. Of course the moononites are an alltime classic

Mailhag is in:

Including this gem of baseball insight: "Geo may argue with me on this, but he isn't the fastest runner, and you do want someone who can run, first to third, at the top of the order." regarding Soto batting third instead of 102 OPS+ Marlon Byrd.

I'm no debater but it seems to me that Soto might have cost the Cubs a run with his baserunning just the other day (Tuesday). This is from Az Phil's post, above:

Geovany Soto reached on a ground rule (fan interference) double leading off the top of the second, but failed to advance to third on a ground-out bouncer over the pitcher's head that would have allowed him to score on another ground out later in the inning.

But does that outweigh the fact that Marlon Byrd is a thoroughly average hitter, even when he has a decent year (for him)? He makes a fair amount of contact, and that's about all he has going for him--he isn't even fast. Soto gets on base and has more power than Byrd. Byrd is just fine 6-8 and acceptable as a #2 hitter if you want someone in the second spot who can put the bat on the ball and hit it to the right side (of course, Castro is fine for that too, and probably runs better).

Byrd is just very overrated by the Cubs front office and by Quade. He looks like a linebacker, he's got a big smile, and he likes to talk to the press (while saying all the right things), but that doesn't make him a cleanup hitter.

[OT: He also likes sentence fragments quite a bit. Somebody needs to tell him to pull that particular stylistic tic back a little bit on his blog.]

I think the formula the Cubs are following is that your #3 hitter is the best combination of speed and power (and contact) in the lineup. Byrd used to be a speed guy in the minors and he still gets around the bases pretty well. I feel like I've seen him slide safely into home half a dozen times. His best statistical number last season was probably the 84 runs he scored. He comes up a little short in the power department but he did have 39 doubles, so those muscles are not completely wasted. He's not the perfect #3, but hey, on a team of #6 hitters (Jim Bowden's description of the Cubs last week) you have to fill the other lineup slots.

I expect Castro to hit third eventually, not this year.

J. Berg 60.75 ERA so far, 2 more runs today

Marmol and J. Stevens the only scoreless innings today

Team ERA back up over 7.00

Uncharted ST territory.

I'm gonna put that in the next edition of my "That Totally Matters" encyclopedia.

Project .450!!

A few hours later, Wren counted himself fortunate to be able to reveal Salazar was interacting with his family members..."We feel very fortunate and blessed that Louie is alive and that he is responding and able to communicate with his family and talk," Wren said...Salazar suffered multiple facial fractures and will need to undergo further tests to better determine the extent of damage done.

Recent comments

Subscribe to Recent comments
The first 600 characters of the last 16 comments, click "View" to see rest of comment.
  • Classic ending, about 12:11 AM, CST. 5 hours, 3 minutes. Both teams have bases loaded, no out situations in the last inning.

    Magic #19.

    Last man on the bench, Montero gets it done.

    Cubster 7 hours 35 min ago view
  • This fucking game

    Baez lucky to not have hurt his hand with headfirst slide on play at plate in 12th inning.

    Rob G. 8 hours 31 min ago view
  • #$@!$!@$!@$#@!$@!$!@#!@!


    crunch 9 hours 36 min ago view
  • Maddon's master plan to challenge his offense to improve on coming from behind late in games is working amazingly.

    Rob G. 10 hours 8 min ago view
  • Everyone remember Starlin Castro dropping or misplaying just about every ball near second base that involved a tag?

    Javier Baez is the opposite of that.

    Rob G. 10 hours 18 min ago view
  • on the wild pitch thing, did they really call that a wild pitch on Jansen that Heyward scored on Friday? If so, I don't know what a passed ball is anymore.

    Rob G. 10 hours 21 min ago view
  • Let's see -- up 3-0, at home, Jake on the mound and contrast 2015 to 2016. Bleh.

    Hopefully, the Pirates will uncork a series of 9th inning wild pitches.

    billybucks 10 hours 24 min ago view
  • modern media

    @BNightengale: Former #MLB pitcher Dan Haren will be throwing to Tim Tebow tomorrow during his tryout in LA, he announced.

     [email protected](dan haren): @BNightengale nope, I was offered the opportunity and declined.

     @ithrow88 Oh and memo to my agent, @bvanwagenen: Pitching to Tim Tebow tomorrow DOES NOT count as getting me a real job offer.

    Rob G. 10 hours 43 min ago view
  • I think the Cub Reporter should be politics free.
    Build Bridges. Don't anyone dare pull out a trump card.

    Cubster 10 hours 52 min ago view
  • The Cub offense is in on the con.

    1-for-10 so far w/RISP.

    billybucks 10 hours 56 min ago view
  • swing and a miss.

    i'm gonna like...go stand over there. *points*

    crunch 10 hours 57 min ago view
  • This is all a long con by Arrieta to lull playoff opponents.

    Rob G. 11 hours 1 min ago view
  • the factual correction on your mistakes on your post that I barely bothered to read the first time because it had nothing to do with anything I wanted to talk about is indeed a sign of my degenerative brain condition. I appreciate the safety tip and will be looking into with extreme urgency now.

    Rob G. 11 hours 23 min ago view
  • it took you 4 posts to get to this?

    have you checked the batteries in your carbon monoxide detector?

    #droppingknowledge #savinglives

    crunch 11 hours 48 min ago view
  • Fwiw, Billy Hamilton's actual WAR numbers that relate to the ones that I posted for Mike Trout are:

    • 2014: 2.5
    • 2015: 1.0
    • 2016: 2.6

    But by all means #crunchsplain on the stupidity of WAR while exaggerating your points. I can't wait to read more.

    Rob G. 11 hours 53 min ago view
  • jacos 11 hours 53 min ago view