Ted Lilly Complains of Knee Pain and Gets His Shoulder Scoped

Ah, another new adventure in Cubbery.

Sorry for missing the day's rampant speculation on Ted Lilly's left pitching shoulder arthroscopy. I was in the OR all day and connecting hip bones to...

So in one hour what can you see during a shoulder scope? Dr. Yokum puts the scope in from the posterior portal, low and behold he sees a caricature of Sean Marshall smiling face on the anterior capsule. He then puts in a Wissinger rod to create an anterior portal and whoa, is that a Tom Gorzellany autograph on his biceps tendon?

As we all remember from a report right here at TCR, the Ted Lilly Chronicles...

Lilly was on the DL as of July 25th after experiencing left shoulder pain that was diagnosed as tendonitis and treated with 3 weeks of rest. In one of the stranger events of the season, he goes on the DL because of his shoulder but because he was going to have to rest his shoulder, he opted to have his knee scoped since it had been acting up for awhile from a torn meniscus. The original plan was for him to tough it out and get the knee scoped after the season but the doctors felt his shoulder pain was a cascade problem stemming from his knee, so the shoulder symptoms changed the gameplan. Lilly did have a shoulder MRI-Arthrogram in July (leading to the DL stint), which was reported to show tendonitis but no structural damage. He returned from the DL on Aug 17 against San Diego and pitched a healthy and strong 6 shutout innings only for the outing to be wasted in one of the more painful losses of the season, courtesy of Kevin Gregg's 4 run ninth inning stint ending with Kyle Blanks walk off HR.

In 2005 with Toronto, Lilly had several DL stints because of left biceps tendonitis which didn't require surgery. His shoulder didn't act up again until around the All-Star break (he was the lone Cub representative last season and didn't get into the game because that is when his shoulder started to ache). 

In the media reports of what Dr. Yokum's procedure found and what he did, we see the terms debridement, washout and cleanup. That doesn't say much really except that some tissue was a bit worn and smoothed off. In this context debridement doesn't refer to removal of dead tissue (just worn tissue, so no maggots were needed) but specific anatomic structures like the biceps attachment to the glenoid/socket or biceps tendon as it enters the shoulder joint, the labrum (fibrous rim of the glenoid/socket) or the rotator cuff aren't specifically mentioned. When they say no structural damage was seen, it means none of the aforementioned items had enough damage to require reattachment. If his problem was biceps tendonitis or minor wear of the rotator cuff tendon (supraspinatus) they might have "cleaned up" these problems without feeling the need to repair or reattach anything. If he did have some signs of inflammation from friction outside the joint, often referred to impingement or bursitis, it's common to reshape the bone that rubs on the cuff (the acromion, which is a part of the shoulder blade/scapula). This is referred to as an acromionplasty and by flattening the front of that bone (it's common to have a curved shape in that area), it opens up the area that rubs on the cuff or biceps tendon where it enters the shoulder joint. Unfortunately, we're not told much from the media reports so I don't know if this was done.  Clearly, this minimalist news is better news than getting reports that he had a capsular shift or tightening (Mark Prior), a labral repair (Angel Guzman, Kerry Wood) or a rotator cuff repair or even a biceps tenodesis  which is a reattaching of the biceps tendon to the upper arm/humerus) and is done when the biceps is severely worn (Curt Schilling's situation which lead to controversy with doctors arguing whether he should have that surgery or not).

In the 6 months from November until late April, there is more than enough time to rehab and recover from a shoulder arthroscopic cleanup without any major structures needing repair. Unless Cubbery intervenes.

Ted Roosevelt Lilly a tough guy so I suspect he'll just do the return to sender thang,  when pitching coach Larry Rothschild sends him the towel drill video. Ultimately we'll know if this surgery worked if it keeps his KNEE from acting up.



Good write up, Doc. Thanks.

Is it likely the tendinitis inflammation from the July MRI-Arthrogram prevented the doctors from seeing the above issues? Or did the MRI likely reveal exactly these issues which they decided to fix surgically?

I think the MRI-Arthrogram matched what they found at the arthroscopy since neither event has identified any "structural" damage. They didn't think he would need to be arthroscoped back in July and if he did have it scoped then it would have ended his season. The recovery from a knee scope can be obviously quicker. The original plan was to have his knee scoped after the season but it got bumped up when his shoulder started aching too. So the timing on these decisions are factored into how much playing time will the surgery impact, but it's far from the final factor which is usually persisting pain over time (usually months).

The Cubs weren't officially out of the race when Lilly's shoulder-knee combo became an issue and they thought he could get back in a 3 week window of time, which was pretty accurate. If that window was longer he might have needed more time just to do the minor league rehab thing. The Cardinals caught fire in August (while Lilly was on the DL) so his absence did have an adverse affect but he wasn't able to pitch with both problems so the decision at that time became fairly obvious.

There can be other factors pointing to the decision to have surgery including what his shoulder physical exam suggests, but in this case persisting pain in the face of nonsurgical management (anti-inflammatory meds and physical therapy) made Lilly eventually decide to have it scoped. It was still Lilly's decision and these are always shades of gray to this decision. Sometimes these symptoms go away with extended rest (i.e. the off season). If the problem cropped up next year after extended rest then they would have been faced with that decision and it would have interfered with his season more extensively so that's a plus to having it done now. Still there is no guarantee that it won't recur even after him getting an arthroscopy depending on what is causing the inflammation, for example if his shoulder is still impinging.

Royals trade Mark Teahen to White Sox...


Dave Van Dyke on WSCR this am said this is the same surgery that Wood had in 2006 and Prior had in 2008.


Most important question, how is TLFC taking this?

Unfortunately, we're not told much from the media reports
so I don't know if this was done.  Clearly, this minimalist news is
better news than getting reports that he had a capsular shift or
tightening (Mark Prior), a labral repair (Angel Guzman, Kerry Wood) or
a rotator cuff repair or even a biceps tenodesis  which is a
reattaching of the biceps tendon to the upper arm/humerus) and is done
when the biceps is severely worn (Curt Schilling's situation which lead
to controversy with doctors arguing whether he should have that surgery
or not).

considering Wood and Prior had different surgeries, I think Van Dyck is just grouping all shoulder surgeries together...

Probably an AZ Phil question here.....

How does MLB insurance work in regards to injured players (Lilly).

Does insurance cover 100% of Ted's contract if he misses 2010?

Will this esentially give the Cubs an extra 10 million to play with in Free Agency?

Elliot Harris, fellow pervert, stole my question for the new owners regarding a ball girl at Wrigley.

And of course he asks the right Rickett about it.



if there's good news is that he's really just had the TJ surgery on his elbow which plenty of pitchers have been able to come back from, looks like he had ankle problems the last year or so that complicated matters..

I can see those reports being extremely effective I am looking hunt commandos in an equatorial jungle or alien life forms in Antartica.

DBags buy out Chad Tracy, put Petit on waivers (claimed by Mariners).

How in the Hell did Hendry miss out on claiming Petit? Was he not injured enough for Hendry's 40 man roster? Will be 25 this year and has great upside. Surely worth a look over Thomas Diamond or Chad Fkn Fox again.

Asleep at the wheel I presume


must be a different Petit out there....

the one claimed by the Mariners gives up a lot of flyballs and has trouble keeping them in the park (13.6% HR/FB rate and 50% of balls hit off him are flyballs)


Safeco is a good place for him to try and not suck....

Not claiming he is a Cy Young candidate. But why not take a flyer on a young guy with average plus stuff. He has had some MLB success. He is only 24.

We've resigned Chad Fox 3 times. We've given 3 seperate contracts to Glendon Rusch. We just claimed Thomas Diamond. Petit is a better bet than any of those dudes are. Especially for nothing more than a waiver claim.

Especially with Lilly hurt.

I don't see how the first two have anything to with it, Fox was a reliever with good stuff and guaranteed to give an extra roster spot come playoff time. Rusch's first signing was a late spring training move and then they resigned him thinking he could duplicate it.

Diamond's got good stuff, top prospect stuff, but had TJ surgery which guys come back from all the time and was of course claimed before Petit hit waivers.

I also assume Petit hit waivers because he's out of options.

Glendon Rusch was collecting a check from the cubs from 2004-2007. 4 years 3 contracts.

My point is that not every move needs to be sexy/high dollar. Petit wouldn't hav cost anything to claim and give a ST invite to. He's probably as good a bet as Randy Wells to have a good year next year. Only he was an actual prospect and is 3 years younger.

When money is going to be scarce, why not roll the dice with some guys like Petit. Maybe one of them turns into something.

Or we can stand pat and just assume that everything works out.

well it costs something to claim a player I believe albeit minimal...

Rusch got cut by the Rangers in 2004 in March, Cubs signed him as a free agent (I assume for not much over the league minimum) and then resigned in Nov of '2004 on a 2-yr deal.


apparently after 2005, he received another 2-yr extension, had that ugly 2006 along with a blood clot and was cut before 2007. He was due to make $3.25M in 2007.

By Fangraphs value tool he well-exceeded his contracts even with the disaster of 2006 and not pitching in 2007.

as for Petit being an actual prospect, then you should love Thomas Diamond.

but I don't see anything in Petit that makes it much of a travesty, especially if he's out of options.

I just want us to take a more proactive approach.

If we don't have money to spend, then we need to do some tire kicking.

To me, the worst thing possible this offseason is for management to decide

1) Ted Lilly will be fine

2) Randy Wells is a legitimate 3rd starter

3) Wells,Marshall,Gorzy will be an acceptable 3-5 in the rotation.

Especially since we don't have 1 single MLB ready Starter at AAA. Travesty to have a 140 million dollar payroll and absolutely zero SP depth.

Petit is useless unless you want a guy to pitch 200 innings and give up 100 homers.

the guy is king of having really good sub-standard pitching and leaving/hanging too much of it in the zone.


Miles talks about bringing back Harden now...

interesting note on Harden...

had a HR/FB% of 15.4% last year, usually you're around 10% I believe and that's mostly where Harden has been for his career (he's actually been below 10% for his career)..

his K rate didn't change much, so I'd expect a big bounce back year from him if he's not on the DL....

For all the complaints about Rothschild (deserved), Harden was very, very healthy while he was here.

I agree.

I cannot see Hendry going into the season with three number 4 or 5 pitchers, and Z who is a "two" at best.

With that possibility, and the always-thin "good" pitching market out-priced for the Rickett's new budget, it would not be a surprise if Harden finds his way into the Cubs' plans again.

Unfortunately, the Cubs will still not have a "Number One", elite Ace starter on the team.

When I watched the Playoffs this year, the Phillies, Yankees, Cards, and Angels all have one (or two).

I am still so fucking pissed at Hendry for his 100-year deal with Soriano.

Knucklehead Hendry.

Abreu signs 2-yr deal with Angels...

JJ Putz will be a FA, another broken wing buy low candidate...

$19 million for two or $27 million for three years on Abreu.


a list of the top 25 seasons for players at various infield positions that excelled offensively and defensively...

Grace, Sandberg , Santo and Stan Hack are on there...

Interesting, although "harmonic mean" is a new one on me, sounding vaguely New Agey. What does it mean?

some fancy way of saying the best balanced seasons...

if all your value came on offense rather than defense, you wouldn't show up on the list or vice-versa....

JJ Putz will be a FA, another broken wing buy low candidate...
Thats all the Cubs need is another Putz.

(da da boom)

Old Mike and Mike joke. But if we pick up Putz and the Astros were to pick up Kevin Mench, we could have a Putz pitch to a Mench. Happy Hanukkah everyone!

The following pitchers are available:
Steve Traschel
Glendon Rusch
Chuck Finley
Tom Glavine
Pedro Martinez (now more than ever)

I'm sure I've forgotten a few. Actually, my pipe dream is Lackey. He and Zambrano would probably kill each other though....

Bartolo Colon
(if you can find him)

Also the Cubs could have a good shot at Vincent Padilla.

~cheap laugh~


these guys have the prospects in the 40-60 range after the 2009 season, seems like Cubs couldn't have gotten in on that....

aaronb rant in 3...2...1

odd player for BOS to spend 4+m on.

Hermida made $2.25M last year and had a poor season, doubt he'll double his salary, $3M tops

personally it's a perfect player for Red Sox to take a shot on, low risk-high reward and they saved a lot of money last year...

yeah, but where to play him? ...and is he going to be happy doing bench/injury work if that's his role?

insurance if they don't get Holliday or Bay I assume, Drew's obviously no guarantee to play all the time either, and not like he won't be tradeable again if he becomes disgruntled...

exactly the type of move a big market team should make especially since the prospects didn't seem to exciting...

It all depends on how you view was is going to shake out in arbitration offers. If a lot of arb eligible guys get non-tendered, and Hermida may have been a candidate for that, then the Red Sox may have paid for something they could have gotten for free. I don't think that's the case, but I think I heard yesterday that 22 teams had declines in ticket sales in 2009.

it was just a pre-emptive strike, they'd have to bid against other teams if Marlins non-tendered him and those other teams could have offered Hermida a better shot at a regular gig.

I'm not even a huge Hermida fan or anything, but two lefty relievers low on the prospect totem pole seems like a good deal for a guy with immense, albeit untapped talent. The road splits are intriguing as well....

Anyway, I say good move by the Red Sox, they obviously believe in his talent as he was a possible acquisition for Manny two years back and Red Sox have some money to burn....

Theo Epstein is a helluva smart guy.

But - the Cubs have Jim Hendry!

take notes Jimbo

 "It was a chance to get a guy with unfulfilled potential for a reasonable cost," Epstein said.



but Tim Floyd does have the honor of being the worst NBA coach ever and did it with the Bulls...

anyway, L.A. casino, girl fight, Tim Floyd...you know you wanna watch..


Tim Lincecum busted for possession of marijuana.

Never saw that one coming...

...and he deserves to be busted for driving around smoking. take that crap back to the mansion, kid.

Well - the Bay Area does have some of the best weed coming down from Humboldt County it is said.


driving around smoking it is pretty damn irresponsible, though. too many people take "smoking and driving" less seriously than they should, imo.

Better than drinking or being pilled out. It's legal out there anyway.

Make that smoking and driving and speeding. Not smart.

But they should just legalize it anyway.

Being high off Marijuana is just as bad as driving drunk, your still impaired and can't operate a motor vehicle properly.

I dunno. Some people (not me, of course) found themselves to be more alert drivers post-puff. They said it was pretty incredible how observant they could be all of a sudden.

Coincidentally, I think there should be a 1-beer law that makes it legal to drink one beer on your way home from the liquor store.

I hearby nominate Jumbo for President!!!!

I appreciate the support. It is probably proof that I am an alcoholic because I truly want that law. I would legalize and tax a few other things and would banish Congress to stuffy side rooms forever.


Especially the House. And especially the Senate. And all Congressional hearings, baseball related or otherwise.

Comparing driving stoned to driving drunk is like comparing apples to shoelaces. People BLACK OUT while drunk. Driving stoned is a piece of cake as long as you don't have to drive too fast or there aren't a bunch of crazy lights around.

apples are mostly red or green, shoelaces are black, brown, red or white...so red apples with red shoelaces would be good for Regis Philbin...vote for Jumbo.

I didn't mention that my house is a 2 minute drive from the liquor store.

Recent comments

Subscribe to Recent comments
The first 600 characters of the last 16 comments, click "View" to see rest of comment.
  • I'm not a denier but definitely a skeptic on Strop and Grimm, who struggle with fastball control. Strop doesn't go near the ninth inning, and note how Grimm couldn't close the deal even with a 5-run lead. So Felix Pena comes in and gets the 3-pitch game-ending strikeout like it was nothing.

    And how about Almora missing that very catchable ball? That was unexpected after all the hype about his glove.

    When Trea Turner misses balls like that--which he does--I draw conclusions from it. It seems to be the one chink in his armor. But I'll give Almora another chance.

    VirginiaPhil 3 min 34 sec ago view
  • Assuming Soler is good to go, I think it comes down to 3 of the following 4: Coghlan, TLS, Sczcur, Almora. Of the 4, TLS seems to be the hardest to justify, particularly given his behavioral issues.

    billybucks 9 min 2 sec ago view
  • I'm wondering if both Coghlan and LaStella make it. With Javy being able to play all the infield spots and Joe maybe wanting late-inning D when Soler plays (assuming he plays), hence either Szczur or Almora, I think LaStella might be the odd guy out.

    Tito 12 min 1 sec ago view
  • Hendricks needs the win, anyway, plus a couple more.

    My hunch is that Hendricks wins the Cy Young . . . for Lester. That is, without Hendricks tipping the scale toward the Cubs, Scherzer tops Lester.

    VirginiaPhil 25 min 10 sec ago view
  • Old Cub fans remember when Ken Hubbs died at 22 in the crash of a small plane he was piloting in a storm in Utah in 1964. But Hubbs was not an elite power pitcher like Score and Fernandez. Score lived a long time after the accident but it was (effectively) career-ending.

    VirginiaPhil 28 min 46 sec ago view
  • HAGSAG: Since I've only seen them throw in one game and in one "live" BP session, all I can do is provide initial first impressions.

    Brailyn Marquez is listed at 6'4 but is probably more like 6'5 or 6'6. I would describe him as a younger version of Bryan Hudson, throwing a ton of ground balls but not getting a lot of swings & misses (yet). Because of his size he could eventually grow into more velocity, but right now he's mostly a pitch-to-contact guy. He generally throws strikes.

    Arizona Phil 34 min 15 sec ago view
  • Phil, do Marquez and Ocampo look like prospects?

    Hagsag 4 hours 18 min ago view
  • It helps when your defense has declared war against the H in WHIP.

    Still impressive.

    John Beasley 4 hours 20 min ago view
  • Lackey finishes with a 3.35 ERA. Currently good for 13th in the NL. Not bad for a guy signed to be a #3 starter in a 15-team league.

    He is also 6th in WHIP. Pretty amazing: Cubs have the #2, #3, #5 and #6 starters in WHIP.

    billybucks 11 hours 15 min ago view
  • Completely meaningless game, but Pena striking out Sean the Turd to with the bases loaded was very fun.

    Other than one bad game in SD, Pena has been very good. Even with that game, 9.0 IP, 13 K, 0.89 WHIP.

    billybucks 11 hours 19 min ago view
  • 101 wins...most since 1910 (104).

    neat. ...or sad. pick one. pick both. 'murica.

    crunch 11 hours 35 min ago view
  • Just looked up Grimm's stats -- after a great run, he gave up 2 runs vs. MIL then didn't pitch for 10 days. Don't remember why?

    billybucks 11 hours 38 min ago view
  • Sean Rodriguez's helmet looks like it's taking a dump

    jacos 11 hours 42 min ago view
  • Grimm not doing himself any favors lately re: making the playoff squad. Seems to have lost the feel for his curveball.

    billybucks 11 hours 46 min ago view
  • j.grimm is literally worse than hitler.

    felix pena, your turn.

    crunch 11 hours 48 min ago view
  • it's been a while since joe's over-managed a game...it's gotta feel good for him to be back in the saddle making people's scorecards look like their pens blew up.

    crunch 12 hours 34 min ago view